History is often said to repeat itself, but more accurately, it is human nature that recurs. Across different eras, human nature remains remarkably consistent. The desires, pride, face-saving, and emotions surrounding power are strikingly similar to those we see today.
The story of Yi Seong-gye, the founder of the Joseon Dynasty, and the Lee An-sa family, a powerful local elite in Jeonju during the late Goryeo period, illustrates this point. Regardless of its factual accuracy, the enduring nature of this tale is not solely due to its mythic origins. It encapsulates the age-old political dynamics of power, humanity, jealousy, fear, and survival.
According to this narrative, the Lee An-sa family was a significant local force in Jeonju. One day, a conflict arose between this local power and the central authority. At the heart of the dispute was a beautiful courtesan, which sparked issues of pride and emotion. While the story is anecdotal and its veracity cannot be confirmed, its underlying structure is intriguing. It represents not merely a love affair but a struggle for dominance in the region.
Central power always claims legitimacy, asserting that it upholds order by royal decree. However, local elites have long held the trust of the people, land, economic resources, and networks. If the power from the center is merely paper authority, then the local elite represents power on the ground. The clash between the two was perhaps inevitable—a confrontation between local elites and central authority.
Power, despite the passage of time, remains astonishingly similar. History often moves not by grand ideologies but by human emotions. Pride provokes power, and face-saving escalates conflicts. In the Goryeo period, a rumor that “royal energy flows from the ancestral graves” could lead to the downfall of a family, illustrating this dynamic. While such beliefs may seem absurd today, in an era lacking scientific advancement, geomancy was not merely superstition; it was a framework for understanding the world and a quasi-science explaining political realities.
When deciding on a capital or constructing royal tombs, people sought to interpret the will of heaven and the energies of the earth. In such times, the phrase “the king is in my grave” was not just a rumor; it was a political attack and sometimes a weapon threatening survival. When human jealousy and the fear of power intertwine, personal emotions can quickly transform into public violence.
Thus, the story of the Lee An-sa family’s grave desecration and their flight becomes even more symbolic. Whether the tale is true or not, it reflects the desperation of a family forced to uproot itself for survival. Relocating ancestral graves is not merely a move; it involves shifting the very foundation of life, memory, and family history. Ultimately, this family, once pushed to the periphery, would find itself at the center of a new dynasty. The oppressed become the powerful, and the periphery becomes the center—a historical irony.
What is fascinating is how history tests humanity in this manner. Power often conceals individuals, only to reveal their true nature at critical moments. Desires, character, restraint, and limits that were invisible during ordinary times become starkly apparent at the threshold of power.
Today's politics are not much different. During election seasons, politicians' pasts are scrutinized. Long-forgotten remarks, youthful mistakes, and personal conflicts resurface for public judgment. Some claim injustice, while others argue that these are old matters. Both perspectives hold some truth. Everyone has immature phases and makes mistakes.
The issue is not the mistakes themselves but what kind of person emerges after those experiences. Power is a test of humanity before it is a test of ability. People do not only read campaign platforms; they observe how candidates respond in crises, how they treat others in conflicts, whether they evade or accept responsibility, and if they can exercise restraint in the face of emotions. A leader's qualities are often revealed more in uncomfortable moments than in grand speeches.
Reflecting on this, the criteria by which communities choose their leaders have not changed significantly over time. People in the Goryeo period likely asked, “Can we trust this person with power?” Today’s voters pose a similar question.
The reason the Lee An-sa tale endures to this day is rooted in this very conflict of pride and emotion that unfolded in a tavern in Jeonju during the late Goryeo period.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.