Trump Responds to Iran's War Compensation Demands with Counterclaims

President Donald Trump has countered Iran's demands for war reparations by asserting that Iran should instead pay compensation. As Iran seeks concessions from the U.S. to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, Trump's introduction of new reparations conditions has further diminished the likelihood of an early agreement.

On August 10, Trump stated on social media platform Truth Social that Iran's request for reparations had never been mentioned in any negotiations. He called it an 'interesting thought' and added, 'Now I, too, demand reparations from Iran.'

Previously, Iran had set conditions for reopening the Strait of Hormuz, including the lifting of U.S. maritime blockades and economic sanctions, the return of frozen assets, the withdrawal of U.S. troops from the region, and compensation for war damages. Iran believes that compensation for damages caused by U.S. and Israeli attacks is necessary to normalize the situation in the strait.

In contrast, Trump argued that Iran should compensate for past U.S. military casualties in the Middle East. He also stated that Iran should pay reparations to the families of protesters killed by the Iranian government's harsh crackdowns. He expanded his demands, saying, 'Iran must also be responsible for damages in Lebanon, Syria, Yemen, and Gaza.'

Trump indicated that he has instructed representatives to firmly raise this issue in all future negotiations, signaling that the U.S. will not only reject Iran's demands but will also make its own reparations claims a formal agenda in upcoming talks.

The negotiations for reopening the Strait of Hormuz are expected to become more challenging. With Iran reaffirming its demands for sanctions relief and compensation, and Trump adding new conditions, the gap between the two sides has widened. Bloomberg reported that 'the immediate possibility of an agreement is low as both sides maintain hardline positions.'

Direct negotiations between the U.S. and Iran are currently suspended. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi stated, 'The two sides are communicating through intermediaries rather than direct talks.' Iran's position is that it will not engage in direct negotiations unless the U.S. properly implements a tentative agreement reached in June.

Meanwhile, negotiations between Iran and Oman regarding the Strait of Hormuz have progressed to the final stages. The two countries are discussing new shipping routes. However, Iran has made it clear that it cannot fully reopen the strait unless the U.S. lifts sanctions and provides compensation, even if an agreement is reached with Oman on shipping routes.

This situation poses a burden on the peace plan that the Trump administration has been considering. According to the Wall Street Journal, Trump has explored the possibility of ending the war even if a final agreement on Iran's nuclear issue is not reached, provided that the Strait of Hormuz is fully reopened. However, with Iran demanding reparations and the withdrawal of U.S. troops, and the U.S. countering with its own reparations demands, finding a breakthrough in peace negotiations has become more difficult.

The two sides also have differing views on the nature of reparations. Trump has claimed, 'Reparations to Iran were never discussed in past negotiations.'

However, the memorandum of understanding (MOU) agreed upon by the U.S. and Iran in June included a provision for the establishment of a $300 billion fund by the U.S. and regional countries for Iran's post-war reconstruction and economic development. The agreement did not explicitly define this as direct war reparations.

As negotiations remain stalled, the Trump administration is prioritizing economic pressure over large-scale military strikes for the time being. The Wall Street Journal reported, citing U.S. officials, that 'Trump has opted for a strategy that increases Iran's economic burden by maintaining financial sanctions and maritime blockades on Iranian ports.'

Trump is currently said to prefer not to order additional airstrikes. He emphasized the effectiveness of economic pressure, stating, 'They are bankrupt.' However, when asked about the possibility of large-scale escalation, he noted, 'If we want to, we have the capability.'

As expectations for negotiations have diminished, international oil prices have surged again. Brent crude rose nearly 5% on August 10, approaching $88 per barrel. Concerns over delays in normalizing the Strait of Hormuz continue to create instability in the global energy market.

Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.