KARACHI, September 20 (AJP) - The political landscape in Germany is undergoing a seismic shift, as evidenced by the recent state election in Thuringia. For the first time since World War II, a far-right party has emerged victorious in a German state election, marking a significant moment in the nation’s post-war history. The Alternative for Germany (AfD) secured a staggering 32.8% of the vote, outpacing the center-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), which managed only 23.6%. This victory for the AfD signals a deepening discontent with Chancellor Olaf Scholz's government, whose popularity continues to wane. Adding to the complexity, a newly established party founded by a prominent leftist also made notable inroads, underscoring the public's appetite for change across the political spectrum. The results have delivered a severe blow to the traditional parties, which are now grappling with the implications of these historic gains by anti-establishment forces.
Germany’s regional elections in Saxony and Thuringia, typically low-profile affairs, have suddenly become a focal point of concern, not just for the country but for the European Union as a whole. The results, which saw extremist parties gaining significant ground, are rattling an already uneasy EU. The rise of populist disruptors is no longer confined to fringe movements; it’s now a full-blown political reality across Europe, especially in the EU's eastern, ex-communist regions. The Alternative for Germany (AfD) is at the forefront of this upheaval, securing substantial votes in both Saxony and Thuringia. Despite other parties refusing to join them in a coalition, the AfD’s strength is poised to make the formation of new state governments a formidable challenge. The emergence of the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW) with nearly 12% of the vote in Saxony and 15.8% in Thuringia adds another layer of complexity to an already fractured political landscape.
The discontent fueling these populist gains is rooted in deep dissatisfaction with a national government mired in infighting, coupled with anti-immigration sentiment and skepticism about Germany’s military aid to Ukraine. The AfD has capitalized on these issues, stoking fears with a campaign centered on anti-migration rhetoric and sensationalized claims of government failure. In the recent state elections, Germany's political landscape is showing signs of fragmentation that could spell trouble for Chancellor Olaf Scholz. While his center-left Social Democrats managed to cling to representation in Thuringia's legislature, their allies in the national coalition, the Greens, were less fortunate, losing their seats entirely. This loss mirrors the fate of the pro-business Free Democrats, who have now vanished from the state legislatures in both Thuringia and Saxony.
The recent attack in Solingen, where a failed Syrian asylum seeker killed three people and injured eight, has become a potent symbol for both the far-right and mainstream politicians in Germany. The tragedy was swiftly exploited to stoke fear and bolster the toxic narratives that extremist parties thrive on. However, the response wasn't limited to the fringes; mainstream politicians also jumped into the fray, calling for harsher asylum laws, increased deportations, and tighter security measures. This environment of fear and reactionary politics paved the way for the Alternative for Germany (AfD) to secure its first state-level victory, despite the party's well-documented ties to right-wing extremism. Before these elections, a significant portion of voters in Saxony and Thuringia identified immigration and asylum policies as their top concerns, with support for Ukraine also serving as a contentious issue. In this climate, fear has been weaponized, leading to a dangerous shift in Germany’s political landscape, where extremism is increasingly normalized.
As Germany approaches its next national election, Chancellor Olaf Scholz faces mounting pressure to adopt a tougher stance on immigration. With his government’s strategy on Ukraine also under scrutiny, convincing voters that this path is essential for safeguarding their freedoms has become increasingly challenging. Yet, no matter how hard Scholz pushes, it seems unlikely that his efforts will quell the rising tide of extremism that has taken root in the country. These extreme movements thrive on misinformation, often fueled by anti-Western narratives, both domestic and foreign. The issue of immigration, a focal point for these groups, is far too complex to be solved by any single nation or bloc. The root causes - conflict, dispossession, and the moral obligation to offer refuge - are intertwined with global dynamics that transcend borders. Yet, in Germany and elsewhere, the surge of populists, nationalists, and alt-right forces prompts uncomfortable questions. Are isolated incidents of violence being weaponized to bolster far-right popularity? As these forces gain traction, the very liberal values that define European societies are at risk of being undermined, leaving a continent grappling with the consequences of fear-driven politics.
The recent electoral success of AfD should not just trigger more infighting within Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s embattled coalition but rather provoke deep reflection in Berlin. The rise of such extremism is rooted in today’s multifaceted challenges - economic stagnation, austerity-driven welfare cuts, and the inflationary pressures squeezing state budgets. Social media, with its capacity to amplify fear and spread disinformation, exacerbates these issues, preying on the most primal human instincts. As these malignant forces gain traction, the responsibility falls on the Scholz government not just to counter the far-right’s narrative but to address the underlying economic and social grievances that fuel its rise. The moment calls for leadership that can inspire hope, not succumb to fear-driven politics.
The fragmentation of Germany's political landscape is a troubling sign for the future of the European project. With Brexit weakening the union and France increasingly polarized by alt-left and alt-right forces, Europe is struggling to maintain its cohesion. Many member states have embraced populism, institutionalizing it as a significant force within their parliaments. This internal division not only threatens the stability of Germany but also undermines the credibility of Western democracies as a whole. In a world marked by international geostrategic discord, where migration can be weaponized, and nation-states destabilized from within, Europe’s disunity makes it vulnerable to external pressures. To preserve its influence and democratic values, the EU must confront these challenges with a united front, or risk losing its balance in a rapidly changing global landscape.
The upcoming election in Brandenburg on September 22 will be crucial, especially with Germany's national election just over a year away. The recent losses for Scholz's coalition partners suggest growing disenchantment among voters, particularly in the eastern states, which could challenge the stability of the current government. The ramifications of this shift extend beyond Germany’s borders, threatening to exacerbate instability within the European Union at a time when the bloc is already facing significant challenges. With Europe still reeling from the effects of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the rise of populist forces in Germany could further destabilize the fragile equilibrium within the EU, adding another layer of uncertainty to an already volatile geopolitical landscape. The political landscape in Europe is shifting, and the ripples from these regional elections will be felt far beyond Germany's borders.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This article was contributed by Dr. Imran Khalid, a freelance writer based in Karachi, Pakistan. He was qualified as a physician from Dow Medical University in Karachi in 1991, and has a master's degree in international relations from Karachi University.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.
