AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Debate Over Expansion or Reconstruction: Who Owns the Party?

Politics enjoys metaphors as they simplify complex realities. However, while metaphors can clarify, they can also obscure the truth. Recently, author Yoo Si-min used the terms 'expansion' and 'reconstruction' to critique President Lee Jae-myung.


Yoo argued that the Democratic Party's supporters desired 'expansion' that maintains the party's existing values while broadening its base, whereas President Lee is pursuing changes closer to 'reconstruction,' which involves dismantling the current structure. He added that reconstruction requires the consent of existing residents.


Yoo's concerns, framed as affectionate advice to the president, deserve respect. Those in power should face stricter scrutiny than the opposition, and the president must first listen to internal criticism. Democracy thrives on critique rather than applause.


However, it is essential to examine the underlying issues.


The crux of this debate is not merely Yoo's criticism of the president. Critiquing the president is a fundamental democratic right. What matters is the premise of that critique. Is the Democratic Party truly a space governed by the consent of 'existing residents'? Is a political party the property of a specific faction? Is the ruling party a museum preserving its past identity, or is it a living political organization that continuously adapts to changing times?


I believe it is the latter. Reflecting on the history of the Democratic Party of Korea, it has been more about 'redesign' than 'expansion.'


Under the leadership of Kim Dae-jung, the Democratic Party was the focal point of the pro-democracy movement against military dictatorship. It addressed the era's challenges of peace, human rights, overcoming regional discrimination, and restoring democracy. That Democratic Party was a political space that faithfully reflected the spirit of its time.


However, the emergence of Roh Moo-hyun significantly altered the political lexicon of the Democratic Party. He directly criticized regionalism, declared a break from vested interests, and initiated a new experiment in participatory politics. The rise of the Reform Party and the founding of the Open Our Party were not mere expansions of the existing Democratic Party; they were a complete redesign of the political blueprint.


At that time, there was considerable opposition. Many criticized the disruption of the existing Democratic Party. However, history remembers this as a political choice in response to changing times.


The Moon Jae-in administration followed a similar path. The Democratic Party, born from the candlelight revolution, took on a different character. The eradication of deep-rooted evils, judicial reform, income-led growth, and the peace process on the Korean Peninsula were new political experiments that previous iterations of the party had never experienced.


The Democratic Party has never existed in the same form. It has changed with each era. When leadership changes, policies shift, and when public demands evolve, the party's philosophy and strategy are also adjusted. This is the essence of a living political party.


Thus, today's Democratic Party cannot be an exception. The growth, practicality, promotion of the artificial intelligence (AI) industry, expansion of corporate investment, and centrist strategies proposed by the Lee Jae-myung administration are open to debate regarding their validity. However, defining the expansion itself solely as 'reconstruction' that dismantles the existing Democratic Party is an overly narrow interpretation of the ruling party's role.


The ruling party becomes a party for all citizens, not just a specific support base, the moment elections conclude.


Similarly, the president transitions from being a candidate for supporters to becoming the president for all citizens upon taking office.


Therefore, policies aimed at the youth are necessary, as are efforts to persuade the centrist electorate. Improving the investment environment for businesses is essential, as is the need to consider both growth and distribution. If all these actions are interpreted as a betrayal of the existing support base, governance becomes impossible, even if electoral success is achieved.


Politics exists not for elections but to improve the lives of citizens.


The term 'existing residents' raises another issue. Regardless of intent, it can imply that the Democratic Party is the property of a specific political faction.


However, a democratic party is not anyone's private property. The dedication of party members who have long supported the Democratic Party deserves respect. The history of generations who sacrificed for democracy is also invaluable. Yet, this should not serve as a barrier to the participation of new generations.


A political party is a dynamic organization. When young people join, the party must learn their language. As the centrist base grows, policies must change. When industrial structures evolve, economic philosophies must adapt. When the international order shifts, diplomatic and security strategies must be redesigned. A party that does not change cannot survive.


Global politics has followed a similar path. The British Labour Party was once centered around strong labor unions. However, Tony Blair declared 'New Labour,' significantly altering the party's identity. There was fierce internal backlash, with many claiming it was no longer 'Labour-like.' Yet, Blair believed that if the times had changed, the party must change as well, and ultimately, the Labour Party succeeded in long-term governance.


The same applies to the Democratic Party in the United States. The transition from the traditional New Deal Democrats to a party encompassing the information technology sector, Silicon Valley, the middle class, and youth involved numerous internal debates. The vitality of a party lies not in preserving its past but in adapting to changing times.


The Christian Democratic Union in Germany and the Liberal Democratic Party in Japan have also survived by repeatedly adjusting their policies. No democratic party in any country aims to preserve its past unchanged.


However, this does not mean abandoning identity. Identity and strategy are distinct. Values must be upheld, but policies can change with the times.


Democracy is about maintaining principles while altering methods. In fact, unchanging politics is more dangerous.


The more pressing issue is the reality facing South Korea today. We do not live in a leisurely era where we can debate 'expansion' versus 'reconstruction.'


AI is fundamentally altering industrial structures. Semiconductors have become national security assets, and data has become the new oil. The United States and China are in direct conflict over technological supremacy, and supply chains have become central to national strategy. Low birth rates and an aging population threaten the sustainability of South Korea's economy. Potential growth rates continue to decline, and young people claim that the ladder of opportunity has disappeared. Regions are concerned about extinction, and manufacturing faces a massive wave of AI transformation.


In such times, politics should not be about determining whose house it is. It should focus on how to redesign the house called South Korea. Politics is not a technique for preserving the past; it is a technique for designing the future. Citizens do not want to see political leaders referring to each other as 'existing residents.'


What citizens desire is a growing economy, stable jobs, fair opportunities, sustainable welfare, and a nation where future generations can hold onto hope. That is the reason for the existence of the ruling party.


Yoo Si-min's advice is worth listening to. Internal criticism aimed at ensuring the success of the administration is always necessary.


However, that criticism must also be re-evaluated in light of changing times. The Democratic Party is not a party for a specific generation or faction. It is a public institution chosen, evaluated, and reshaped by the people of South Korea.


Thus, what the Democratic Party needs is not just the consent of existing residents but also the trust of young people who have yet to cross the threshold, the empathy of the centrist electorate, and the expectations of future generations.


A political party does not exist to preserve an old house. It exists to build a house where citizens can live more safely and comfortably.


Whether it is expansion or reconstruction, that is a matter of method. What is more important is the essence of whose house it is.


This is the question that South Korean politics must now answer.





* This article has been translated by AI.