The unprecedented server outage that occurred just before the deadline for the 2027 college admissions applications has sparked significant backlash. Following a one-hour extension of the application period, concerns about potential unfair practices, dubbed 'vacancy raids' (where students change their applications based on revealed competition rates), have prompted the education authorities to consider canceling applications submitted during this time.
In response to the growing fallout, teachers' unions have issued statements highlighting the structural flaws of relying on a few private companies for such a critical national process and are calling for the establishment of a public application system.
On September 15, the Education Ministry and the Korean Council for University Education (KCUE) released a report on the measures taken regarding the Uway application system outage, outlining principles for relief and follow-up actions. The Education Ministry stated, "We will provide relief based on objective data but will not acknowledge any unfair cases."
Major teachers' unions, including the Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union (KTU), the Korean Federation of Teachers' Associations (KFTA), and others, have issued statements from September 14 to 16, pointing out the chaos in schools caused by this incident and demanding accountability from the education authorities while emphasizing the need to enhance the public nature of the admissions system.
Addressing 'Vacancy Raids': Reviewing Cancellation of Suspicious Applications
The education authorities are focusing on preventing any unfair practices that may have occurred during the one-hour extension. There are allegations that some students checked the final competition rates released by certain universities immediately after the deadline and used the extended time to switch their applications to programs with lower competition rates.
According to the Education Ministry, 17 universities disclosed their competition rates during the extension period, which was initially set to close at 6 p.m. on September 11. The ministry is currently verifying applications submitted during the extended time at these universities and stated, "We will consult with the universities and consider canceling applications identified as suspicious, such as those involving strategic maneuvering."
Not All 1,200 Non-Applicants Will Be Granted Relief: Strict Criteria Required
Initially, over 1,200 students were reported to have failed to submit their applications even after the deadline extension. However, not all of them will receive relief.
To prevent indiscriminate relief, the Education Ministry and KCUE have established three strict criteria: 1) Applicants must have error logs from the system outage around 5:50 p.m. on September 11; 2) There must be a record of application attempts (including writing, saving, submitting, or payment attempts) for the university they are applying to; 3) If there are multiple application records, only the last submission will be considered for relief.
An official from the Education Ministry predicted, "Applying these strict principles will significantly reduce the number of students eligible for relief from the initial 1,200."
Teachers' Unions Unite in Criticism: Call for a Public Application System
The most significant confusion during the resolution process has been experienced in schools. Complaints from students and parents, who feel that only those who submitted their applications early are at a disadvantage, have been directed at teachers. Consequently, teachers' unions have collectively criticized the education authorities for their complacent response and the reliance on private companies for the application process.
The KTU stated in a September 15 statement, "This incident stems from a structural issue where the fate of students is concentrated in the hands of a few private profit-making companies. The government must establish a public application system that ensures stability and fairness."
They also demanded that the responsibility for handling relief applications and complaints not be shifted to schools and teachers, urging the Education Ministry and KCUE to take direct responsibility.
The KFTA echoed this sentiment, stating, "This cannot be dismissed as a simple technical error or a one-time incident. The final responsibility for such a crucial national admissions process cannot be left to private entities, and we must reassess whether the current private-centered application system sufficiently guarantees public interest."
Additionally, the Teachers' Union Federation and the Secondary Teachers' Union emphasized that students who followed school guidance and submitted their applications on time should not be placed at a disadvantage. They called for transparency regarding the circumstances surrounding the outage, the extension, and the disclosure of competition rates, urging the establishment of a unified channel for addressing grievances directly.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.