AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Coway Files Design Infringement Lawsuit Against Chungho Nice

Comparison of Coway's Noble Air Purifier and Chungho Nice's Summit Tower Air Purifier
Comparison of Coway's Noble Air Purifier (left) and Chungho Nice's Summit Tower Air Purifier [Photo=Coway]

Coway has filed a lawsuit against Chungho Nice, alleging design infringement related to its Summit Tower air purifier. This marks the first official legal action following the establishment of a design monitoring task force in January, aimed at protecting design intellectual property rights.
According to industry sources on June 16, Coway submitted a complaint to the court on June 2, claiming that Chungho Nice's Summit Tower air purifier, launched in February, infringes on the design rights of Coway's Noble air purifier.
The specific issues raised by Coway include the square shape and proportions of the main body, the design of the upper pop-up section, and the structure that allows the upper pop-up section to move vertically. Coway argues that these elements closely resemble the key design features of the Noble air purifier, resulting in a similar overall aesthetic.
This lawsuit has escalated beyond a mere product similarity dispute to a significant issue of design rights protection. Coway applied for the relevant design rights in December 2020, prior to the launch of the Noble air purifier, and completed the registration in April 2021. The Noble series has since become a flagship design product for Coway in the premium air purifier market, leading the company to view the launch of similar products as a potential infringement on its brand assets.
Coway contends that Chungho Nice's product launch is not merely a coincidental similarity in appearance but rather an unauthorized use of the achievements built through Coway's investment and efforts. Consequently, Coway believes this constitutes not only a design infringement but also an act of unfair competition under the Unfair Competition Prevention Act.
In the home appliance industry, competition for premium products has expanded beyond performance to include design aesthetics and suitability for interior spaces, making design rights disputes a key issue for brand differentiation.
In January, Coway became the first in the industry to launch a design monitoring task force to establish a continuous response system for similar and imitative designs. This lawsuit is the first official legal action taken since the task force began operations.
Kim Ki-pyo, head of Coway's design monitoring task force and compliance division, stated, "Design is a core asset that embodies the technology and creativity accumulated by a company over many years. We will respond to intellectual property infringement in accordance with principles to maintain a fair competitive environment through the protection of legitimate rights."



* This article has been translated by AI.