AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Lawyers Warn of Imminent Wave of Delistings, Stressing Court's Role in Protecting Companies

From left, Park Hyun-soo and Cho Jun-woo of Law Firm Gwangjang during an interview with Aju Economy on June 15.
(From left) Park Hyun-soo and Cho Jun-woo of Law Firm Gwangjang during an interview with Aju Economy. [Photo by Yoo Dae-gil]
As the July 1 deadline for stricter delisting criteria approaches, companies are increasingly anxious, particularly those on the brink of collapse. In light of these heightened concerns, we sought advice from the Delisting Response Team at Law Firm Gwangjang.
 
What Sets the Law Firm's Delisting Response Team Apart?
Park Hyun-soo: Responding to delisting is often described as a "comprehensive art form." It requires simultaneous expertise in litigation, responses to the Korea Exchange, finance, accounting audits, taxation, and corporate rehabilitation. Few large law firms possess strength across all these areas. Law Firm Gwangjang has direct experience with the GammaNu case and boasts specialists like former Chief Judge of the Securities Division at the Seoul Southern District Court, Seong Chang-ho, and former head of the Securities Crime Joint Investigation Team at the Seoul Southern District Prosecutor's Office, Park Kwang-bae. We have a well-organized system for forming project teams tailored to the specifics of each case.

Cho Jun-woo: I have served as a member of the KOSDAQ Disclosure Committee and the KOSDAQ Listing Disclosure Committee. The key to responding to the exchange is effectively communicating in the "language of the exchange." The roles of advisors with exchange backgrounds are significant, and we have recently welcomed many experts from the Financial Supervisory Service and the Financial Services Commission, including Chan Moon-seok and Shin Sang-rok. Our team includes professionals from various levels of the Financial Supervisory Service, from practical staff to senior officials. Although the exchange is a civil litigation adversary, it operates largely according to the policies of financial authorities, making these experts crucial in strategy formulation.
 
Park Hyun-soo of Law Firm Gwangjang during an interview with Aju Economy.
Park Hyun-soo of Law Firm Gwangjang during an interview with Aju Economy. [Photo by Yoo Dae-gil]
 
Impact of the GammaNu Case on Delisting Regulations
Park Hyun-soo: The GammaNu case is essentially the only instance of a definitive ruling that invalidated an individual delisting decision by the exchange. At that time, the exchange had a structure that mandated immediate delisting upon a single rejection of the audit opinion. The delisting decision was made in September 2018, and after receiving a provisional injunction, the audit opinion changed to a favorable one just four months later in January of the following year. The court ruled, "Why would you hastily kill a company that could be revived with just a little more time?" Law Firm Gwangjang won in all three instances of the trial.

Since this case, three significant changes have occurred. First, the requirements for re-audits have been relaxed. Previously, a company had to undergo a re-audit within six months of receiving a negative opinion, which was nearly impossible. This has since been improved to allow for a new auditor to provide a favorable opinion in the following year. Second, confusion arose when a provisional injunction was granted during the orderly trading period. For seven years prior, no provisional injunction had ever been accepted, so when the exchange initiated orderly trading, a decision on the injunction came about four to five business days later. This led to a new practice of suspending orderly trading upon confirmation of a provisional injunction application. Third, the review process for the Delisting Review Committee has changed. Previously, 15 companies were reviewed in a single day, with GammaNu being the 14th. By the time you reach the 14th company, the committee members can hardly see the documents. We even called a professor from the accounting department who participated in the committee as a witness for questioning. Now, the review process has shifted to examining only one or two companies per day.
 
Is the Recent Regulatory Change a Step Backward?
Park Hyun-soo: Following the GammaNu case, the exchange has become more cautious in its procedures, allowing for sufficient improvement periods. Consequently, since the GammaNu case, there have been no instances where a court has definitively invalidated a delisting decision made by the exchange.

The issue is that negative side effects have emerged. Companies that should be delisted are not being removed in a timely manner, leading to discussions around the "Korea Discount," which has contributed to the background of this regulatory change. In some ways, this reflects a return to the pre-GammaNu situation, albeit with a more cautious structure that includes a requirement for two consecutive years of negative audit opinions.
 
Future Court Judgments and Litigation Strategies
Park Hyun-soo: Due to the regulatory changes, we expect a surge in delisted companies over the next one to two years. As the number of cases increases, there will undoubtedly be instances where companies are hastily delisted, leading to potential misjudgments. This could cause courts to become more vigilant, resulting in a higher likelihood of overturning exchange decisions compared to the past. Recent cases like Jeil Bio and Cellpie Global can be viewed in this context.
 
Insights on the Recent Injunction Decision for Cellpie Global
Park Hyun-soo: The surface reason for the delisting is embezzlement and breach of trust; however, underlying this is the fact that there were two consecutive years of negative audit opinions. The re-audit yielded a favorable opinion, and the former management and largest shareholder were replaced, leading minority shareholders to unite to secure management rights and attempt to save the company. The court's perspective is essentially, "This is a company that could be revived if given the chance; why would you delist it without providing any opportunity?"

The legal principle is similar to the GammaNu case. It argues that "failing to provide a reasonable improvement period for a company that could be revived constitutes an abuse of discretion." There is a possibility that the exchange may shift towards granting improvement periods. The delay caused by the injunction effectively provides an improvement period. However, from the exchange's standpoint, there is a burden to overturn its own judgment, making it difficult to predict their actions.
 
Cho Jun-woo of Law Firm Gwangjang during an interview with Aju Economy.
Cho Jun-woo of Law Firm Gwangjang during an interview with Aju Economy. [Photo by Yoo Dae-gil]
 
Defensive Strategies for Companies Facing Stock Price Requirements
Cho Jun-woo: The requirement for 45 consecutive trading days is honestly a challenging mission. Therefore, our initial advisory direction is paradoxically focused on fundamental restructuring. While attempts to reduce the likelihood of penny stock status through stock consolidation or reverse stock splits are possible, these are merely temporary fixes. Companies need to enhance their intrinsic value through new business development, mergers and acquisitions, and improved communication with shareholders. Share buybacks and increased investor relations activities can also be effective strategies.

Park Hyun-soo: This regulatory change sends a strong signal that surviving on short-term fixes will be difficult. Once a company is designated as a management issue or has its trading suspended, the stigma effect makes it extremely challenging to recover within a few days. If such cases arise this year, companies will realize by next year that they need to seek expert assistance proactively to survive.
 
How to Respond to Strengthened Market Capitalization Requirements
Cho Jun-woo: Market capitalization requirements cannot be resolved through stock consolidation. There needs to be actual stock price increases or capital increases through new stock issuance. Ultimately, positive developments must occur within the company. This is why I believe that mergers and acquisitions among small listed companies will become more active. Following the amendment of the Commercial Act, directors must consider not only the company's interests but also the interests of shareholders, necessitating more nuanced legal advice than before.

In the venture sector, there are many calls for easing or deferring requirements, but for the time being, it seems the government will proceed according to its policy. The government has shown a willingness to accept over 100 delistings, indicating a mood of trial and observation.
 
Are Advisory Strategies Different by Industry?
Cho Jun-woo: While there are not significant differences, there are cautious aspects for biotech companies. Many have failed to generate revenue after listing under technology-based exceptions, leading to situations where fundamental changes are difficult to recommend. Realistically, attracting external funding or pursuing mergers and acquisitions are the most viable alternatives.

Park Hyun-soo: There are industry-specific differences as well. The structure has changed to evaluate companies based solely on semi-annual performance, which affects seasonal industries with significant performance fluctuations between the first and second halves of the year. For IT companies, orders are placed at the beginning of the year, and payments are received at the end of the year, which can make first-half performance appear poor. Effectively communicating this seasonality to the exchange can be a specialized strategy to avoid immediate delisting based solely on semi-annual results.
 
How to Address Audit Opinion Deficiencies Leading to Delisting?
Park Hyun-soo: The leading cause of delisting is audit opinion deficiencies, followed by embezzlement and breach of trust, and then inadequate disclosures. In the GammaNu case, we argued that "audit opinion rejections are not a monolith but exist on a spectrum." There are gray areas where auditors issue negative opinions to avoid liability, even when the situation is close to acceptable. In many advanced countries, audit opinion deficiencies are rarely treated as formal grounds for delisting.

With the strengthening of auditor independence and accountability, the number of negative opinions has significantly increased. The recent regulatory change has established a structure where two consecutive years of deficiencies will lead to automatic delisting, but there will undoubtedly be companies that find this unjust. Such companies must seek redress in court, and that is where we come in.



* This article has been translated by AI.