AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Why Forensic Science Remains Outside the Courtroom

"The results from the National Forensic Service are in."

This phrase is commonly encountered in legal reporting. Whether in murder cases, industrial accidents, or medical malpractice, the findings from the National Forensic Service (NFS) often serve as pivotal points in investigations. In today's world, DNA evidence, digital forensics, and CCTV analysis have become stronger than confessions.

However, a question arises: While the NFS is a well-known national agency, why is it rare to see private forensic experts or forensic scientists passionately debating in court?

Yoon Oe-chul, a senior advisor at the law firm Jipyeong, recently provided insight into this issue, attributing it to the judicial system. A forensic science expert who led the introduction of profiling in South Korea during his time with the police, Yoon's diagnosis was surprising. He argued that for forensic science to advance further, the adversarial system must be genuinely established, rather than merely investing in more equipment.

South Korea's criminal procedure law aims for an adversarial system. However, in practice, records and results from police and prosecution investigations continue to heavily influence trials. In contrast, in countries like the United States, the courtroom serves as a battleground for evidence. Prosecutors submit DNA analyses or forensic results, which defense attorneys can challenge through expert witnesses, allowing forensic scientists and forensic experts to present their opinions in court.

Ultimately, the difference lies in 'demand.'

For experts to thrive, there must be a market seeking their expertise. A structure that actively utilizes expert opinions in trials is necessary for forensic scientists, digital forensics experts, and medical evaluators to establish their careers. This would also lead to the emergence of research institutions and companies. Yoon emphasized that "demand must be created for supply to follow."

Without demand, experts are not drawn to the field. Yoon cited forensic pathologists as an example. The physical and mental burden of facing corpses and determining causes of death through autopsies is significant. If they must endure much lower compensation than general practitioners despite holding medical licenses, who would willingly choose forensic pathology? He pointed out that in a structure where only a sense of mission sustains professionals, it is challenging to cultivate talent.

Of course, the adversarial system is not a panacea. An increase in expert evaluations can prolong trials and raise costs. There must also be an expansion of judges and court personnel. The efficiency of the current structure, which aims to process cases quickly, cannot be overlooked.

Nevertheless, there are benefits. A system where private experts re-evaluate evidence presented by the state and publicly contest those findings in court increases the likelihood of arriving at substantive truth. Most importantly, it broadens the opportunities for the wrongfully accused to prove their innocence. The goal of the criminal justice system is not merely to expedite cases but to reach the correct conclusions.

Another noteworthy aspect is that this issue extends beyond judicial procedures. As the private forensic science market grows, encompassing medical evaluations, digital forensics, and accident reconstructions, the number of professionals will increase, and related industries will expand. Changes in the legal field could lead to new jobs and technological competitiveness, indicating that the system can foster industry growth.

Our forensic science has already reached a considerable level. What is now needed is not just competition to enhance the capabilities of national agencies but an ecosystem that extends expertise to the private sector. A country where both the NFS and private experts collaboratively verify evidence is closer to a mature judicial system than one that relies solely on a strong national agency.

The adversarial system is not merely a call to change trial procedures. It is a foundational system aimed at reducing wrongful accusations, nurturing experts, and broadening the base of forensic science. The next stage of forensic science should begin not with more equipment but with more vigorous courtroom debates.
 
Photo by Won Eun-mi
[Photo by Won Eun-mi]
 




* This article has been translated by AI.