Valuations for SK Hynix's American Depositary Receipts (ADRs) are sharply divided among financial analysts. Barclays has set a target price of $330, citing a memory supply shortage, while Morningstar has assessed the fair value at $160.
On July 14, Investing.com reported that Barclays initiated coverage on SK Hynix ADRs with an 'overweight' rating and a target price of $330. This figure represents a 117% increase from the closing price of $152.35 on July 13 and suggests about 70% additional upside compared to the July 14 closing price of $193.92.
Barclays anticipates that the shortage of memory semiconductors will worsen by 2027 and will not be fully resolved by 2028. The firm noted that while demand for memory used in artificial intelligence (AI) servers is rapidly increasing, there are limits to expanding production.
Barclays also projects that SK Hynix will maintain over 50% market share in the high-bandwidth memory (HBM) sector, which is crucial for AI applications due to its ability to stack multiple DRAM chips for faster data processing.
The impact of Chinese competitors on the global DRAM market is expected to be limited, as major global cloud providers are unlikely to adopt Chinese-made DRAM in their data centers, which would prevent significant changes in the existing market structure.
Barclays positively assessed the potential for increased share buybacks, estimating that SK Hynix will have cash and easily liquidated assets exceeding 40% of its current market capitalization by the end of 2027.
HSBC also expressed a positive outlook on the memory market, suggesting that it is too early to conclude that the memory sector has peaked, given ongoing investments in AI servers and rising DRAM prices. HSBC identified SK Hynix as its top pick among Korean tech stocks, predicting it will maintain a 50-55% share in the next-generation HBM4 market.
In contrast, Morningstar has set a fair value of $160 for SK Hynix ADRs, which is about 17% lower than the July 14 closing price of $193.92. Morningstar believes the current stock price is somewhat high relative to the company's value and rates the uncertainty of future price predictions as 'very high.'
While acknowledging the rapid growth in demand for AI memory, Morningstar pointed out that the performance of memory semiconductors can fluctuate significantly based on price and supply changes. It noted that despite SK Hynix's lead in the HBM market, the company is not immune to competitive pressures and the risk of declining memory prices.
Morningstar also highlighted the premium at which ADRs are trading compared to their Korean counterparts as a concern. The difficulty in freely exchanging Korean stocks and ADRs limits arbitrage opportunities, which could lead to excessive premiums on ADRs if demand from U.S. investors surges. Given that the ADR is still in its early stages, the stock price may experience significant volatility as it seeks to establish a fair price differential.
On that day, SK Hynix ADRs closed at $193.92 on the New York Stock Exchange, up 27.3%. Since its listing on Nasdaq at an offering price of $149 on July 10, the stock has seen increased volatility amid growing expectations for AI memory growth.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.