AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Government Reveals Harmful Ingredients in 465 Tobacco Products, Detects Carcinogens in E-Cigarettes

The South Korean government has disclosed that harmful substances, including formaldehyde, classified as Group 1 carcinogens by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), have been detected in all tobacco products currently on the market, including traditional cigarettes and e-cigarettes previously considered less harmful. This marks the first time the government has scientifically analyzed and transparently published the harmful ingredient levels in tobacco products.


The Ministry of Health and Welfare and the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety announced on October 29 that they are releasing the results of harmful substance tests for 465 tobacco products, following a review by the Tobacco Harm Management Policy Committee. This follows the implementation of the Tobacco Harm Management Act on November 1 of last year.


Previously, cigarette packaging only indicated nicotine and tar levels, along with the presence of six carcinogenic substances. However, this new initiative provides detailed information on the specific harmful substances and their quantities in individual products, including e-cigarettes.


The testing covered 465 products from 20 manufacturers and importers that were available at the time the law took effect, including 256 traditional cigarettes, 104 heat-not-burn products, and 105 e-liquids.


Testing agencies measured 44 components in traditional cigarettes and heat-not-burn products using the World Health Organization's recommended enhanced collection method, reflecting actual smoking habits. For e-liquids, the analysis focused on the concentration of 20 substances per gram, resulting in a total of 46 harmful substances being examined.


The results revealed that nicotine (0.8 to 2.6 mg per cigarette) and tar (11.7 to 40.4 mg) were detected in all 256 traditional cigarette products. Notably, formaldehyde (39.5 to 181 µg), benzene (19.6 to 99.9 µg), 1,3-butadiene (12.2 to 277 µg), and cadmium (15.5 to 320 ng), all classified as Group 1 carcinogens by the IARC, were found in every product. Other harmful substances, including nitrosamines specific to tobacco, such as NNN (found in 255 products at 4.5 to 650 ng) and NNK (found in 255 products at 4.3 to 439 ng), as well as benzo[a]pyrene (found in 255 products at 4.6 to 42.1 ng) and arsenic (detected in 171 products at 1.3 to 14.6 ng), were also confirmed.


Similarly, the 104 heat-not-burn products tested showed no safety from harmful substances. All products contained nicotine (0.1 to 1.2 mg per stick) and tar (10.3 to 32.0 mg), with formaldehyde detected in all products (5.4 to 12.1 µg).


Group 1 carcinogens NNN and NNK were found in 87 (2.0 to 54.9 ng) and 88 (1.0 to 25.9 ng) products, respectively, and one product contained benzo[a]pyrene (3.6 ng).


In the 105 e-liquid products, nicotine (5.7 to 20.0 mg/g), propylene glycol (156 to 515 mg/g), and glycerin (283 to 625 mg/g) were detected in all items. These solvents can produce carcinogens during heating and oxidation. In fact, 99 out of 105 e-liquids contained formaldehyde (3.0 to 83.8 µg/g), while some products also showed traces of NNN (2 products), NNK (1 product), and arsenic (2 products).


The government cautioned consumers against mistakenly believing that lower levels of specific substances indicate a 'less harmful' tobacco product. Tobacco smoke contains approximately 7,000 chemicals and over 70 carcinogens, making it impossible to avoid cancer risk even with minimal exposure.


Additionally, substances marked as 'below quantification limit (NQ)' do not mean they are absent; rather, they are below the minimum detection threshold of the analysis equipment. The measurement units for traditional and heat-not-burn products (per stick) differ from those for e-liquids (per gram), making direct comparisons inappropriate.


The government plans to strictly regulate misleading advertising that suggests certain products are less harmful based on selective reporting of test results, applying the National Health Promotion Act and the Act on Fair Labeling and Advertising.


Furthermore, the government aims to tighten regulations on new tobacco products and additives that have previously been in a regulatory gray area. Synthetic nicotine products, which were incorporated into the legal definition of tobacco with the revised Tobacco Business Act on April 24, will undergo harmful substance testing and public disclosure starting next year. Products using 'similar nicotine' liquids to evade taxation will also be evaluated for harmfulness by December, with plans for comprehensive regulatory measures.


The government will develop standard devices and testing methods to measure actual emissions from e-liquids and will conduct a detailed review of the mechanisms of key additives, such as menthol, which enhance nicotine effects and increase dependency, to inform future regulations.


Kim Yong-jae, Deputy Minister of Food and Drug Safety, and Son Young-rae, Director of the Regional Essential Public Health Office at the Ministry of Health and Welfare, co-chair the Tobacco Harm Management Policy Committee. They emphasized, “The mere fact that some substances were detected in lower amounts should not lead to the conclusion that these products are less harmful. It is crucial to understand that all tobacco products are harmful, and smokers should strive to quit for their health, while non-smokers should avoid starting.”


Detailed information on harmful substances by product can be found in the 'Tobacco Harm Information' section of the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety's website. Additionally, individuals wishing to quit smoking can seek assistance through quitline services, local health center clinics, and medical treatment services, as well as access various quitting resources on the quit smoking guide website.





* This article has been translated by AI.