One week after the announcement of 151 low price-to-book ratio (PBR) companies, stock market reactions varied significantly. While the average stock price of KOSPI companies saw a slight increase, KOSDAQ experienced a decline. Consumer staples showed strength, whereas the information technology (IT) and financial sectors struggled. Future evaluations of corporate value will hinge on performance and actual shareholder returns.
On November 6, the average return for 96 KOSPI companies was 0.28%, compared to a 2.43% decline for 55 KOSDAQ companies, indicating a larger drop in the latter. Among the 151 companies, 93 saw their stock prices fall, significantly outnumbering the 56 that rose, while 2 remained unchanged.
In KOSPI, 53 out of 96 companies experienced stock price declines, and in KOSDAQ, 40 out of 55 companies fell. This contrasts with the first trading day after the announcement on November 2, when 115 companies saw gains. The initial excitement following the announcement did not translate into sustained stock price increases.
By sector, consumer staples led with an average return of 4.65%. In contrast, the IT sector, comprising 23 companies, saw an average decline of 3.86%. Other sectors, including finance (-3.51%), healthcare (-2.11%), consumer discretionary (-0.45%), materials (-0.48%), and industrials (-0.27%), also showed weakness. Notably, all five financial companies on the list experienced stock price declines.
The Korea Exchange disclosed the 151 companies on November 1, which fall within the bottom 25% of KOSPI and the bottom 10% of KOSDAQ based on PBR over the last six half-years or six out of the last seven half-years. PBR, which is the ratio of market capitalization to net assets, indicates that a value below 1 suggests a company's market value is assessed lower than its book value. The expectation of a reevaluation of low PBR stocks, combined with government policies aimed at enhancing corporate value, has drawn attention to these companies as potential investment alternatives.
However, a low PBR does not guarantee an increase in stock prices. The market may undervalue companies that have low profitability or inefficient asset utilization. Investors focusing solely on low valuations risk falling into a 'value trap,' where stock prices do not improve as anticipated. Therefore, it is essential to consider not only PBR but also profit growth, cash flow, financial health, and shareholder return policies.
Many companies on this list have remained undervalued for extended periods. According to Hanwha Investment & Securities, 86 of the 151 companies (57%) have been in the bottom PBR category for the last 12 half-years, or six consecutive years. Notable examples include Hyundai Steel, Lotte Shopping, and E-Mart. Even if their PBR temporarily improves, these companies may find themselves back on the list in May 2027 due to their long history of undervaluation.
For long-term undervalued companies, the potential for reevaluation may depend on performance improvements. Hyundai Steel's net profit is projected to rise from 100.3 billion won this year to 308.7 billion won next year. Similarly, Lotte Shopping's profit is expected to increase from 329.6 billion won this year to 414 billion won next year. Recovery in profitability could enhance shareholder return capabilities through increased dividends and stock buybacks, laying the groundwork for a reevaluation of corporate value.
The key question remains whether plans to enhance corporate value will translate into actual management improvements and shareholder returns. Park Se-yeon, a researcher at Hanwha Investment & Securities, stated, "While the disclosure deadline has prompted plans, mechanisms are needed to ensure these lead to actual shareholder returns. Including dividend and stock buyback performance as criteria, publicly sharing compliance with targets, and designing public buyout offers alongside mandatory buyouts could be effective strategies."
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.