AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Challenges in Apartment Lottery System Highlight Need for Reform

In Seoul's competitive apartment lottery, four-person households are increasingly finding it difficult to secure a winning score. Instances of applicants changing the addresses of parents who do not live with them to boost their points have raised concerns about the need for reforms in the point allocation system and verification of dependent status.


According to a comprehensive analysis by Aju Economy of the results from the point-based lottery for 29 privately sold apartment complexes in Seoul from July 2022 to October 2023, 24.1% of the complexes had winners scoring 79 points or higher. This analysis excluded unsold units and cancellations by members.


The lottery point system awards a maximum of 32 points for the duration of being without housing, up to 17 points for the length of bank account membership, and a maximum of 35 points for the number of dependent family members. A four-person household can receive 20 points for three dependents, meaning the highest possible score is 69 points. To achieve 79 points, at least five dependents are required.


In five complexes, including Jamsil Leel and Banpo Raemian Trinwon, 411 out of 457 general supply units had a minimum winning score of 70 points. This means that applicants with three dependents were unable to win in these categories. The lottery allocation is separate.


Conversely, the proportion of large families in Seoul is minimal. According to the 2025 national census data, only 2.75% of households have five or more members, and just 0.49% have six or more.


Cases of inflated family size in the lottery have also been uncovered. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and the Office for Government Policy Coordination reported that they identified 354 suspected fraudulent applications among approximately 25,000 units sold across 43 complexes nationwide from July 2022 to March 2023. The majority, 334 cases, involved fraudulent residency registrations aimed at meeting local residency or housing requirements or increasing points for dependents.


One applicant residing in Bundang was found to have registered his mother living in Yeosu and his mother-in-law living in Gwangju as residents at his address, subsequently winning a general supply lottery in Seoul.


Similar issues have arisen in the special allocation for supporting elderly parents. According to data from Democratic Party lawmaker Jeong Il-young, 132 out of 133 fraudulent applications detected in the special allocation for supporting elderly parents from 2024 to 2025 involved fraudulent residency registrations.


To qualify as a dependent family member, direct descendants must be registered on the same household registration for at least three years as of the application announcement date. Additional criteria include the applicant's status as the head of the household and the housing ownership status of direct descendants.


The government has begun cross-referencing medical facility usage records of parents, the workplace locations of children, and rental histories of household members to investigate actual residency. All identified cases will be referred for investigation, and if confirmed as fraudulent, actions such as contract cancellations and a ten-year ban on applying for lotteries will be enforced.


Park In-sook, a legislative researcher at the National Assembly's Legislative Research Service, stated, "The scores of those who received housing through the point system indicate that the number of dependents is indeed a decisive factor. Since the number of dependents determines the outcome, it appears that fraudulent registrations and the creation of large families have occurred. It is now time to revise the point system related to dependents."





* This article has been translated by AI.