“I initially proposed it, but now I think it would be better to eliminate such an exam altogether.” This statement from Park Do-soon, a professor emeritus at Korea University and the first head of the Korea Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation (KICE), sharply critiques the cracks in the towering structure that has supported South Korea's college entrance system for over 30 years.
The documentary film The Creator of the CSAT, which sheds light on the 30-year history and shadows of the CSAT, premiered on November 10 with a press screening and a media briefing. As the film is set to be released on November 25, the discussion at the briefing was filled with urgent voices hoping to open a public discourse on college admissions reform, moving beyond the temporary fixes that recur every admissions season.
The film explores the origins of the CSAT, which was introduced to shift away from rote memorization tests and measure higher-order thinking skills and comprehension, while granting universities more autonomy in admissions. However, the original intent has been lost, as the exam has transformed into a single, massive hurdle that ranks students by single-point increments, creating a 'Frankenstein' of a system that perpetuates private education cartels.
The 'Trap of Discrimination' Hidden Behind 'Fairness': Parents and Professors Share Their Experiences
Following the screening, director Baek Jin-woo, along with participants including Min Se-jin, an economics professor at Dongguk University, Lee Jong-gak, an emeritus professor of education at Kangwon National University, and parent Kang Sang-woo, engaged in a lively Q&A session.
Participants shared their experiences and the profound pain they face as both parents and education experts. Kang Sang-woo, who took the first CSAT in 1994 and is now a parent of a high school senior, remarked, “When the CSAT was first introduced, it was interesting because it focused on comprehension. I cannot understand why there are now killer questions (extremely difficult questions) in the exam. If one question can determine success or failure, how is that different from the past memorization tests?”
Min Se-jin, who is preparing for his second child's entrance exam under the new high school credit system, viewed the film through an economist's lens. He noted, “The number of newborns has halved compared to those born in the 1990s, yet the college enrollment rate has reached 70%, meaning the competition for actual college spots has increased. While everyone calls for fairness, the reality of what people mean by fairness is essentially 'discrimination.'” He added, “As private education techniques have advanced to extremes, the exam inevitably becomes more difficult to distinguish between the top grades.”
Introducing AI Grading and Written Formats: A New Alternative or Another Layer of Complexity?
Discussions also touched on the proposed introduction of written and essay formats and AI grading for the CSAT, which are currently being debated by the National Education Commission.
Min Se-jin cautioned, “Just as there are now academies focused on mastering AI interviews for job placements, if we introduce written and essay formats and rely on AI grading, private education will quickly adapt by exploiting specific keywords and grading algorithms. This could lead to another 'Frankenstein' scenario.”
Conversely, Lee Jong-gak urged a fundamental shift in perspective. He argued, “What the National Education Commission should truly consider is not how to change the exam format, but how to escape from the exam system itself. We need an 'exit strategy.'” He emphasized, “In the AI era, conducting exams that test fixed knowledge is a national waste and a disservice to students and parents. The government and schools must shift from a supply-driven mindset of 'we provide good education, so follow us' to genuinely questioning what tangible benefits public education can offer to students and parents.”
“The CSAT Reflects Our Society”... A Call for Reflection
At the end of the media briefing, director Baek Jin-woo expressed the message the film aims to convey, warning against 'institutional omnipotence.'
Baek stated, “When I first planned this documentary, I thought fixing the system would solve the problems. However, through repeated investigations, I realized that the issues are not just about specific groups or bureaucrats, but are tied to the desires and civic consciousness of our society.”
He concluded, “In the documentary, even the creators of the CSAT, like Professors Park Do-soon and Kim Young-chae, lament that 'the system we created is not what we intended.' The CSAT ultimately serves as a 'distorted mirror' reflecting the desires of Korean society.” He hopes the film will encourage audiences to reflect on “what values and attitudes we hold towards our children” and foster a mature public discourse.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.