AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

National Judges' Conference Calls for Measures on Evidence Exclusion by Prosecutors

 

Amid ongoing confusion in court proceedings regarding the revised criminal procedure law that restricts prosecutors' evidence collection and submission, the National Judges' Conference has demanded that the Court Administration Office develop measures and provide an official explanation.

On November 10, the Judicial System Committee of the Judges' Conference posted a notice on the court's internal network titled, 'Request for Explanation from the Court Administration Office Regarding Article 245-13 of the Criminal Procedure Law.'

The revised provision allows prosecutors to hear opinions from parties involved in a case or receive materials to verify facts for determining whether to prosecute or maintain a case, but it completely excludes the evidentiary value of statements and materials obtained during this process. This has led to disputes in court over how to handle evidence submitted directly to prosecutors by complainants or witnesses during the trial phase.

The Judges' Conference pointed out, "Evidence that was previously submitted to the court without issue through prosecutors is now being blocked or challenged as illegally obtained evidence due to the impact of the revised law. This inevitably leads to delays in trials."

The committee has requested specific explanations from the Court Administration Office regarding its understanding of the legislative intent behind the revised provision, the confusion faced by trial courts, and the judicial administrative measures being considered to address these issues.

According to internal regulations, once Kang Dong-won, the chair of the Judges' Conference, follows the official request procedure, a representative from the Court Administration Office is expected to attend a future meeting to clarify their position.

Meanwhile, the regular meeting of the Judges' Conference, originally scheduled for December 7, has been rescheduled to take place early on the 30th due to rising internal concerns over threats to judicial independence.

In addition to issues related to the criminal procedure law, various amendments to internal regulations aimed at addressing judicial issues will be discussed at this meeting. Proposals include measures to respond to the indiscriminate submission of documents using artificial intelligence (AI) and a plan to expand the regular meetings from twice a year in April and December to three times a year by adding a meeting in September.

The proposed amendments, initiated by five judges including Kang Hyun-gu of the Seoul Rehabilitation Court, aim to shorten the intervals between meetings for timely responses to current issues and to strengthen the election process for representatives of the Supreme Court Chief Justice Recommendation Committee.





* This article has been translated by AI.