Fifteen primary dealers (PDs) involved in collusion during government bond auctions are facing sanctions from the Fair Trade Commission (FTC), placing the Finance Ministry under pressure to ensure fair bidding and stable bond issuance. The ministry plans to review the qualifications of the colluding PDs after observing the court's ruling.
According to the Finance Ministry on November 11, the current regulations governing the issuance of government bonds and the operation of PDs stipulate that actions significantly disrupting market order, such as bid collusion, can lead to suspension or cancellation of PD qualifications. However, the actual imposition of sanctions is left to the discretion of the issuing authority.
A ministry official stated, "The FTC's imposition of penalties is an administrative decision and can be contested in court. We will consider the qualifications of the PDs after observing the final decision."
During the FTC's deliberation process, the Finance Ministry explained the unique characteristics of the government bond issuance market and the potential impact of large-scale sanctions on it. The official noted, "We have continuously communicated the special considerations of the government bond market before the FTC's decision and attended the plenary session as a witness to detail the differences from general markets."
The FTC also confirmed in a briefing that it reflected the Finance Ministry's opinions in determining the penalty rates and reduction criteria. However, it clarified that there was no evidence that the ministry allowed collusion or facilitated information exchange through administrative guidance.
The Finance Ministry's burden stems from the structure of government bond issuance. PDs are key buyers that must purchase a significant proportion of the bonds issued by the government. To ensure stable bond issuance, the government imposes purchase obligations on PDs while providing benefits such as non-competitive purchase rights and financial support. This structure requires maintaining bidding fairness while encouraging financial firms to continue purchasing government bonds.
The government's bond issuance scale is set at 225.7 trillion won this year, following 226.2 trillion won last year. With over 200 trillion won in bonds needing to be absorbed by the market annually, active participation from PDs in bidding is crucial. The financial investment industry expresses concerns that large penalties could dampen purchase demand, potentially preventing the government from issuing planned amounts or forcing it to accept higher interest rates. There are also worries that rising government bond rates could spill over into other bond markets, such as corporate bonds.
Additionally, the completion of the World Government Bond Index (WGBI) inclusion this month adds another variable. If PDs' market-making functions weaken during a period of increased foreign investment, it could negatively affect liquidity and trading conditions in the bond market. However, the Finance Ministry believes that considering Korea's fiscal soundness and the attractiveness of government bond investments, foreign demand will remain as long as interest rate conditions are favorable.
The Finance Ministry is committed to closely monitoring the situation in the government bond market. An official stated, "We are continuously communicating with PDs and closely checking bidding rates, but there have been no unusual trends indicating a decline in bidding rates yet." Should market instability arise, the ministry plans to consider adjustments to the volume and method of bond issuance.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.