AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Court Rules Against Korea Zinc's Voting Rights Limitation on Youngpoong

Korea Zinc faced a legal setback when a court ruled that the company must cancel a resolution from its annual shareholder meeting last March that limited Youngpoong's voting rights using cross-shareholding regulations.


On November 12, the Seoul Central District Court's 29th Civil Division, led by Judge Ko Seung-il, ruled in favor of MBK Partners and Youngpoong, who had filed a lawsuit seeking to annul the shareholder meeting's resolution.


The court explained that "Korea Zinc cannot restrict the voting rights of existing shareholders by applying cross-shareholding provisions for the purpose of defending management rights." The specific reasons for the ruling were not disclosed in court.


The contested shareholder meeting took place on March 28, 2026. At that time, Korea Zinc claimed that its Australian subsidiary, Sunmetal Holdings (SMH), had acquired over 10% of Youngpoong's shares, establishing a cross-shareholding relationship. Consequently, Korea Zinc limited Youngpoong's voting rights on its 25.4% stake based on Article 369, Section 3 of the Commercial Act.


In response, MBK and Youngpoong filed a lawsuit in May 2026, arguing that the cross-shareholding limitation was illegal.


The first-instance court ruled that the limitation on voting rights led to a change in the company's bylaws, capping the number of directors at 19 and canceling the appointments of both internal and external directors based on that limit. This conclusion contradicts the court's previous provisional ruling.


However, with appeals pending in the higher courts, the impact of this ruling on the ongoing management dispute at Korea Zinc is expected to be limited. For instance, the term for Korea Zinc's directors is two years, and since the first-instance ruling took 1.5 years, it is likely that the terms of the directors appointed at that time will have expired by the time the appeals are resolved. The ruling is unlikely to affect next year's annual shareholder meeting.


If the first-instance ruling is upheld, the limit on the number of directors will be lifted, potentially allowing MBK and Youngpoong, who hold a larger stake in Korea Zinc, to secure a more favorable position on the board.


Korea Zinc plans to review the first-instance ruling and file an appeal promptly.


The company stated, "The first-instance court's ruling that 'existing shareholders' voting rights cannot be restricted for the purpose of defending management rights' contradicts existing Supreme Court precedents and the Supreme Court's ruling in this case regarding the exercise of voting rights. In previous related cases, the court recognized the legality of the procedures and measures we took, so a more thorough examination of the legal interpretation and judgment of this first-instance ruling should be conducted in the appellate court."





* This article has been translated by AI.