The Seoul High Court dismissed a lawsuit filed by some victims' families seeking to return compensation payments related to the Sewol ferry disaster.
On November 12, the court's Civil Division 5-3, consisting of judges Kang Seong-hoon, Song Hye-jeong, and Kim Dae-hyun, upheld the first ruling regarding the lawsuit filed by Kim and over 300 others against the government.
A dismissal occurs when the legal requirements for a claim are not met, terminating the case without a substantive hearing.
The first ruling, made in January, dismissed the lawsuit on the grounds that the settlement process had already concluded with the payment and receipt of compensation. The court did not accept claims that the government's responsibility had been overlooked.
The compensation decision is considered part of a settlement process rather than a judgment, making it difficult to recognize an omission of judgment as grounds for retrial, especially since the 30-day period for filing a retrial request had already passed.
The judges remarked, "This was a significantly difficult case," and requested understanding regarding the legal judgment. However, they did not disclose specific reasons for the ruling in court.
Previously, the 4·16 Sewol Ferry Disaster Compensation and Review Committee determined in March 2015 that the compensation for each victim would be 100 million won.
In June of that year, separate from this, the government decided to provide a total of 300 million won in consolation payments, which included 50 million won from the national budget and 250 million won from public donations.
Among the victims' families, 355 rejected the compensation and filed a lawsuit against the government and Cheonghaejin Marine Company for damages.
The remaining families accepted the compensation but later filed a separate lawsuit to cancel the compensation decision and a state compensation lawsuit in December 2018, following revelations of the government's inadequate rescue efforts and allegations of surveillance of victims' families by the Military Security Command.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.