AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Who Bears the Cost of Time Value During Appeals?


1st instance defendants sometimes deposit the judgment amount in court while appealing the ruling. This is due to the uncertainty of when enforcement may occur, especially since the interest on delayed payments can jump from 5% to 12% starting the day after the ruling. However, it is common for the creditor to refrain from collecting the deposit. This is because the debtor does not acknowledge the debt, and if the appellate court's decision changes, the creditor must return the money with delayed interest.

In cases where creditors do not collect the deposit from debtors who dispute their obligations, lawsuits are ongoing regarding whether delayed interest continues to accrue. For instance, if a deposit of 1 billion won is made, the delayed interest for one year alone exceeds 100 million won. This is not a trivial amount. Yet, the courts have provided differing answers to this question.

Delayed interest pertains to the time value of money. 10 billion won a year from now cannot be equated to 10 billion won today. Ultimately, the issue revolves around who bears the cost of time value during the appeal process. This is a common concern in all lawsuits involving monetary payments. However, there has yet to be a definitive ruling from the Supreme Court.

The argument for halting the accrual of delayed interest is based on Article 487 of the Civil Code, which states that a debtor can discharge their obligation by making a deposit if there are grounds for doing so. It does not require the creditor to collect the deposit for it to be effective. One of the purposes of making a deposit is to prevent the accumulation of delayed interest. If interest continues to accrue simply because the creditor does not collect the deposit, there would be no reason to make one. The debtor suffers a double burden by losing the benefit of using the deposited money while also incurring interest. The creditor's inability to use the money is due to their own refusal to accept it. According to this view, the creditor bears the cost of time value during the dispute.

Conversely, the argument against halting the accrual of delayed interest posits that a deposit is a mechanism for those who acknowledge their debt and seek to eliminate it. A deposit made under a judgment with a provisional enforcement order is conditional on the appellate court potentially overturning that judgment. The Supreme Court stated in 2011 that this is not a definitive discharge of the debt but rather a conditional deposit that loses its effect if the appellate court cancels the enforcement order or the main judgment. The depositor can reclaim the money until the creditor collects it. If merely depositing money that can be retrieved at any time is considered repayment, it would impose an obligation on the winning creditor to collect the deposit. This issue arises only when the debtor's appeal is ultimately deemed unjustified. According to this perspective, the debtor bears the cost of time value.

I represent one side in a case involving this issue and believe the latter view is correct. In the 'Supreme Court Case Commentary' published shortly after the ruling, a judicial researcher noted that since the deposit was made under a provisional enforcement order, the debtor cannot evade liability for delay. However, the point of this discussion is not which side is correct.

The problem is that there has been no clear answer to this question for a long time. The 2011 Supreme Court ruling addressed whether the deposit should be returned in the appellate court but did not directly determine whether delayed interest ceases to accrue. Thus, interpretations of that ruling vary. Some lower courts have ruled that delayed interest ceases to accrue, while others have ruled that it continues to accrue.

Last January, the Supreme Court dismissed an appeal regarding a second-instance ruling that stated delayed interest continues to accrue, without further deliberation. This was an opportunity to clarify a contentious issue, but the ruling only stated that the grounds for appeal did not warrant further examination. Consequently, both parties are now arguing over that single paragraph. One side claims the Supreme Court endorsed that conclusion, while the other argues it is meaningless since it was not a substantive judgment. The lack of reasoning has led to this confusion.

Lower court rulings are similarly inconsistent. Even when parties submit multiple briefs directly opposing the Supreme Court ruling and its commentary, there are instances where the ruling does not even mention that precedent. It is not that the lower court rejected it; rather, it simply did not address it. While lower courts should have the freedom to reach different conclusions from the Supreme Court, it is difficult to justify the freedom to reach a conclusion without any explanation.

Five years ago, I wrote about rulings lacking reasoning in this space. At that time, the party without reasoning was the one who had filed the lawsuit. Now, some lower courts are issuing rulings that contradict the Supreme Court's decision to dismiss appeals without deliberation. This is because they do not fully understand the Supreme Court's intent in dismissing the appeal. As a result, different courts provide varying answers to the same question, determining the fate of the money based on which court it is in.

To address the inconsistencies in lower court judgments, the Special Act on Appellate Procedures should be amended to require that even in cases of dismissal without deliberation, a brief explanation be provided. When reaching a conclusion that differs from a Supreme Court ruling on an issue, the reasoning should be included in the judgment.

While the money remains in the deposit office during prolonged litigation, the burden of its time value does not disappear; it falls on one of the parties. Therefore, the question of who should bear that burden must be answered by the court.



* This article has been translated by AI.