AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Zelensky: U.S. Asks If Ukraine Would Withdraw from Donbas for NATO Membership

In the ongoing U.S.-mediated negotiations for a ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine, the possibility of exchanging Ukraine's NATO membership for a withdrawal from the eastern Donbas region has been raised for the first time. Ukraine, which has maintained a firm stance against territorial concessions, indicated it might consider a referendum on the matter if solid security guarantees are provided.


On November 14, Volodymyr Zelensky, the President of Ukraine, told reporters that he had been asked by U.S. representatives about this issue during recent negotiations.


Zelensky stated, "The U.S. asked, 'What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would that mean withdrawing from Donbas?' This is the first time such a question has been raised." He reaffirmed that Ukraine has no intention of withdrawing its military from the Donbas region and will not recognize Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory as part of Russia. However, he expressed willingness to consult the public if a comprehensive security package, including specific guarantees from NATO and the European Union (EU), strong military support, and post-war reconstruction funding, is assured.


Zelensky emphasized, "If the U.S. and other NATO partners provide such guarantees, I will ask the Ukrainian people what they think. Whether they would accept it or not. I do not have the right to make that decision alone."


However, he clarified that the U.S. has not yet made any concrete proposals, and details are still being worked out. The White House has not confirmed whether such a proposal was made.


The key issues of NATO membership and territorial disputes have now been linked in the negotiations, but it remains uncertain whether Russia will accept this. Russia has consistently viewed Ukraine's NATO membership as a "red line" and has strongly opposed it.


According to a report by The New York Times, Russia is demanding that NATO revert to troop and base levels from before its eastward expansion in 1997 during these negotiations. This demand reportedly includes a halt to NATO military activities not only in Ukraine but also in Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia.


Kaja Kallas, the EU's High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, criticized Russia on November 13 for attempting to use the restructuring of European security as a bargaining chip in the ceasefire negotiations.


Previously, delegations from the U.S., Russia, and Ukraine held three-party ceasefire talks in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, from November 10 for two days but failed to reach a breakthrough. Following that, U.S. Special Envoy Jared Kushner and Special Envoy Steve Witkoff met separately with Russian President Vladimir Putin and President Zelensky.


Meanwhile, European leaders have agreed on the composition of a team to participate in future ceasefire negotiations. During a meeting in Dublin, Ireland, on November 13, they decided to form a negotiating team comprising France, Germany, Italy, the United Kingdom, Poland, and EU institutions.


However, the Kremlin has not yet fully agreed to the participation of European representatives in the negotiations.





* This article has been translated by AI.