The Supreme Court ruled that franchisees or dealers must prove how the use of background music benefited the headquarters in order to claim unjust enrichment, even if they played music without permission. The court stated that merely supplying music to stores does not automatically create an obligation for the headquarters to return profits.
According to legal sources on November 16, the Supreme Court's first division overturned a lower court ruling that partially favored the Korea Music Copyright Association in its lawsuits against Hankook Tire & Technology and LG Electronics, sending both cases back to the Seoul Central District Court and the Seoul High Court, respectively.
The music copyright association had allowed a music service provider to transmit music via the internet in real-time, and playing this music in stores constitutes a 'performance' under copyright law. The association sued Hankook Tire and LG Electronics for infringing performance rights by playing music in T Station and LG Best Shop without separate permission.
In the Hankook Tire case, the lower courts recognized about 9.42 million won of the 146.92 million won claimed by the association. They found that Hankook Tire benefited from providing music services not only to its directly operated stores but also to franchisees, aiding in attracting franchisees and generating commission income.
The Supreme Court determined that the entity playing the music in franchise stores is the franchisee operator. It noted that various factors, such as brand recognition, product quality, and transaction conditions, influence the number of franchise stores and commission income. Therefore, specific evidence is required to establish that the music service directly contributed to the headquarters' profits.
As a result, the remand court must examine whether Hankook Tire received compensation for providing music to franchisees and whether the music played actually increased the number of franchise stores or commission income.
The LG Electronics case marks the second remand. In the first appeal, the Supreme Court ruled that the music used for store services did not qualify as 'sales records' under the previous copyright law, thus infringing performance rights. The remand court subsequently ordered LG Electronics to pay 40.188 million won to the music copyright association for aiding in music playback.
In the re-appeal, the Supreme Court focused on the fact that the operator of LG Best Shop is either a subsidiary of LG Electronics or an individual entrepreneur. It stated that the mere possibility of profits from store operations being distributed as dividends does not imply that those profits accrued to LG Electronics. The court also instructed a review of whether the music played actually increased the number of LG Electronics dealerships or product sales.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.