In late July, in a corridor of an international conference hall in Manila, Philippines, Japanese Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi awaited Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi. There was no prior appointment. Following instructions from the Prime Minister's Office, Motegi sought an opportunity to engage with Wang, planning to casually approach him as he had learned of Wang's schedule. When Wang finally appeared, Motegi greeted him with, "It's been a while." Wang did not acknowledge him and continued walking. Although Motegi walked alongside Wang for a while, he received no response.
The Japanese government later announced that the two had exchanged brief greetings and discussed bilateral relations. However, China's account differed, with the Foreign Ministry dismissing the notion of a meeting. The Yomiuri Shimbun characterized the incident as a symbol of Japan's desire for dialogue being rejected by China. What events transpired over the past year that made even brief contact between the two nations' top diplomats so difficult?
During the APEC summit in Gyeongju on October 31 last year, the two leaders met face-to-face for the first time since Takaiichi Sanae became Japan's Prime Minister. They shook hands and agreed to promote a "strategic reciprocal relationship." However, just a week later, on November 7, Takaiichi made her notable remarks in the Diet regarding a potential military response from Japan if China were to attack U.S. forces near Taiwan. This clear stance marked a departure from previous Japanese leaders who had intentionally left such matters ambiguous. It was an unexpected response not included in the anticipated questions prepared by bureaucrats.
China reacted strongly to Takaiichi's comments about the Taiwan issue, which it considers a core interest, leading to a diplomatic spat that included the expulsion of diplomats. After Chinese Consul General in Osaka, She Zhen, posted on social media that "that dirty neck must be cut off," Takaiichi instructed that if She was not recalled to China promptly, she should be expelled. Japan anticipated that the situation would resolve with the mutual expulsion of one diplomat from each side. However, when a Foreign Ministry official conveyed this to Beijing, China responded, "If one is expelled, we will expel two." Faced with this unexpected escalation, Takaiichi decided to postpone the expulsion of She. According to a Japanese government official, this was a precarious decision aimed at leaving room for dialogue.
Although the expulsion was postponed, China opted for economic pressure instead. In January, it tightened export regulations on dual-use items, including rare earths, which are crucial for Japan. Since the 2010 "rare earth shock," when China halted exports, Japan has reduced its dependency on Chinese rare earths from 90% to 60%. However, the items China restricted were those Japan could not easily replace. Rare earths are divided into common "light rare earths" mined globally and the more valuable "heavy rare earths," which China effectively monopolizes. From January to September this year, China's exports of heavy rare earths like samarium decreased by 98%, while exports of light rare earths like cerium oxide increased by 12%. This means China is restricting items that Japan can only source from them while still selling what can be obtained elsewhere.
A Chinese Communist Party official revealed to the Yomiuri Shimbun, "Japanese companies must not escape dependence on China. We will neither save nor kill them." This indicates that China intends to maintain leverage over rare earths while allowing just enough access to prevent Japanese companies from relocating. Japanese trading companies are feeling the impact. One executive noted, "We have to break down our application amounts to get approvals," suggesting that China seems intent on keeping Japan in a precarious position without allowing stockpiling.
Tourism has also been affected. Due to the Chinese government's advisory against travel to Japan, the number of Chinese visitors to Japan dropped by 55.5% from January to September this year. In contrast, the overall decline in foreign visitors was only 2.9%, indicating that only Chinese tourists have turned away.
Economic pressure is also detrimental to the side applying it. The issue lies in the differing levels of reliance between the two nations. According to the Nihon Keizai Shimbun (Nikkei), China's share of Japan's trade has generally exceeded 20% since 2009, while Japan's share of China's trade has decreased from 13% in 2005 to 5% last year. While China holds leverage through rare earths, Japan's options for leverage have diminished significantly.
In the past, when political relations soured, the business sector would often open back channels. For instance, during the cooling of relations due to then-Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's visit to Yasukuni Shrine in 2005, Hiroshi Okuda, then-chairman of Keidanren, secretly visited China and met with then-President Hu Jintao to pave the way for improved relations. Now, even those back channels have become difficult to navigate. The Japan-China Economic Association, which includes Keidanren's chairman, has visited China almost every year for half a century, but this year, it postponed its January visit. A Keidanren official told the Nikkei, "Everyone in China is now only paying attention to President Xi's intentions. Nothing will move unless the leaders meet first." This indicates that without signals from the Communist Party leadership, the Chinese side is unwilling to engage with Japanese business leaders, reversing the previous order where the business sector would initiate dialogue.
While the business sector struggles to take action, former Foreign Minister Takeishi Iwaya visited Beijing at the end of September. Although he was there in a private capacity, it marked the first official meeting between a former Japanese minister and Chinese leadership since Takaiichi's remarks. Iwaya presented a solution to Wang Yi, who demanded a retraction of Takaiichi's comments, suggesting that Takaiichi reaffirm existing agreements, such as the 1972 Japan-China Joint Communiqué, and accept them as a de facto retraction. Wang, however, maintained China's position, stating, "You can retract or correct it."
The next day, Iwaya hurriedly requested rare earth export permits from Vice Premier He Lifeng. However, the waiting room his delegation was shown to was labeled "Taiwan Room." The rooms in the Great Hall of the People are themed around various Chinese provinces, and the implication that Taiwan is a province of China was evident as the Japanese delegation waited. An accompanying official interpreted this as a message from China reiterating its stance. Whether it is for improving relations or addressing rare earth issues, the hurdle remains Takaiichi's comments on Taiwan.
Looking ahead, will the two nations meet again at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen on November 18-19? Japan has sought a formal summit during this APEC meeting to improve relations, but according to the Asahi Shimbun, China is unlikely to soften its hardline stance, making a meeting difficult.
In contrast, leaders from the U.S., China, and Russia are set to hold their first trilateral summit at APEC on November 19. For host country China, this is an opportunity to showcase its status. A former senior U.S. government official told the Nikkei that Xi may aim to create a narrative of Takaiichi being isolated. Ultimately, Japan may only expect a brief conversation with Xi while standing at the edge of the conference hall. A senior Japanese government official remarked, "Even a handshake could serve as a catalyst for something." A year after meeting Xi in Gyeongju, Japan now awaits even a simple handshake.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.