AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Judicial Delays: Lee Jae-myung's 34 Days vs. Han Duck-soo's 6 Months

“Delayed justice is not justice.” This statement was made by five Supreme Court justices in May 2025 when they overturned a guilty verdict against Lee Jae-myung, then a presidential candidate from the Democratic Party, regarding election law violations. They also noted, “Our Constitution and laws guarantee the right to a speedy trial.”


This reflects the Supreme Court's swift handling of the case. The court received Lee's case on March 28, 2025, assigned it to a panel on April 22, and immediately decided to refer it to the full court, holding its first deliberation that same day. After a second deliberation two days later, the court issued its ruling on May 1, resulting in a guilty verdict. The entire process took just 34 days, with only 9 days from the referral to the final decision.


Now, 18 months later, the “judicial clock” under Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae is facing scrutiny again, this time for being “too slow.”


The Supreme Court is set to conclude the appeal of Han Duck-soo, the former Prime Minister sentenced to 15 years in prison for his involvement in a coup, just before his detention period expires at midnight on November 20. Initially, the court announced a second full court session for November 19. As speculation grew that Han might be released due to the expiration of his detention period, the court issued an unusual notice on November 13, urging restraint in reporting that a ruling would not be possible before the expiration. On November 16, the court confirmed it would announce its decision at 4 p.m. on November 19, the day before the deadline.


Both cases are significant, as a single judicial decision can shake the political landscape and society at large. One involves the political fate of a leading candidate ahead of the presidential election, while the other addresses the criminal responsibility of a former Prime Minister during a state of emergency.


However, the timelines differ drastically: one case concluded just 9 days after referral to the full court, while the other is approaching the maximum detention period of 6 months. While it is natural for different cases to require varying lengths of deliberation, the judiciary must avoid giving room for political interpretations regarding both the outcome and the speed of proceedings, especially in politically sensitive cases. The reasons for delays or expediency must be explained through legal principles and procedures.


As the gap widened, political reactions intensified. With the possibility of Han's release, discussions about impeaching Chief Justice Cho resurfaced within the Democratic Party, with some party leaders claiming, “It can only be seen as a deliberate delay to release Han Duck-soo.”


Coincidentally, the Supreme Court decided to announce its ruling just one day before the expiration of Han's detention period amid rising controversy. This situation raises further concerns, as it could be perceived that the judiciary acted under political pressure.


Judicial independence cannot be maintained by mere declarations. The perception that the judiciary speeds up when the ruling party pushes and slows down when the opposition protests undermines judicial independence. The judiciary must ensure that it does not leave any doors open for political interference.


The authority of the judiciary does not stem from the Supreme Court seal on a ruling document but from the public's belief that “everyone is judged by the same principles, regardless of who the defendant is.” If the speed of trials begins to vary based on individuals, the conclusions of those rulings will inevitably be interpreted politically.


Equality before the law is insufficient if it only applies to individuals; the “judicial clock” must also reflect equality before the law.





* This article has been translated by AI.