AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Defense Ministry Investigates Military's Position Reports During December 3 Martial Law

It has been confirmed that the Defense Ministry Investigation Headquarters is investigating whether there were orders to not report the positions of troops heading to the National Assembly during the December 3 emergency martial law. Prosecutors have revealed that No Sang-won, a former intelligence commander, directed the troops deployed to the National Election Commission.

The key issue is whether there were individuals who received field reports and moved troops outside the regular command structure during the deployment to the National Assembly.

According to a comprehensive report by Aju Economy on the 16th, the Defense Ministry Investigation Headquarters, led by Park Jeong-hoon, has completed its investigation of the complainants in a case filed by the Civic Group and military communication system developer Kim Hyun-seok, and has charged unknown individuals, notifying the Defense Ministry Prosecutor's Office of the charges. The investigation team is also questioning communication personnel as witnesses and has secured the identities of field officers from the 707 Special Mission Battalion and the Special Warfare Command, as well as pilots and co-pilots who operated helicopters during the martial law.

The investigation headquarters confirmed that a 'December 3 folder' and a list of commands remain in the battlefield management terminal. The battlefield management terminal is a computer device used to understand the location and operational status of field units and to exchange commands. The investigation headquarters is also examining the operational guidelines for the Special Forces' use of satellite positioning report equipment (PRE) and how it was operated during the martial law.

The main content of the complaint states that there were upper-level orders to either not carry or cease using PRE among some martial law troops, and that some military helicopters dispatched to the National Assembly deviated from normal flight control. Kim, who filed the complaint alongside the Civic Group, has participated in military communication system development for about 27 years. He was responsible for the development of satellite PRE at Arion Communications and for the maintenance and technical support of equipment supplied to the military.

In the complaint, the Civic Group and Kim requested, "Please investigate the exclusion of satellite PRE usage and the circumstances of military helicopters deviating from flight control, as well as the command structure that decided and directed this and its relation to the execution of insurrection." They argue that if troops were deployed to prevent the National Assembly from voting to lift the martial law by excluding position reports and deviating from flight control, the person who issued the orders should be held accountable for important duties related to insurrection.

They also requested an investigation into allegations of coercion against subordinate soldiers. The complaint includes a need to verify whether there were threats of 'disciplinary action, personnel disadvantages, or physical harm' for disobeying orders, and whether this led subordinates to follow illegal commands.

The field officers whose identities the investigation headquarters requested from related units include regional commanders and team leaders who could have carried PRE at the time. After confirming their contact information and current workplaces, they plan to select individuals for investigation.

Helicopters Heading to National Assembly: 12 Deployed, 4 Observed by Whistleblower

The operation control room monitors the troop locations displayed on the situation map to understand how far troops have moved and where they have gathered. If no position information is sent from the field, troop movements may not appear on the screen.

Previously, former allied commanders and corps-level commanders, as well as former key positions in the Joint Chiefs of Staff, explained that operational information collected by the Special Forces command is typically linked to the Joint Chiefs of Staff's situation system. Kim stated, "If the situation map was functioning normally, the Joint Chiefs of Staff or other commanders would have been able to confirm the overall troop operational status." He suggested that if only some units were displayed on the situation map, it might indicate an attempt to limit knowledge of troop movements from the beginning of the operation.

The Civic Group and Kim argue in the complaint that the directive to exclude PRE usage was intended to make it difficult to ascertain troop locations and movements within the normal command and control system. They raised the possibility that if the same directive was issued to multiple units, it could be linked to the upper command's order for troop deployment and urged an investigation into the individuals who issued the orders and the means of communication.

The special investigation team of the prosecution revealed in December 2024 that the 'Lotteria meeting' involved an individual outside the regular command structure giving orders to active-duty soldiers. At that time, No Sang-won, who did not have military command authority, was found to have directed colonels from the intelligence agency to go to the Central Election Commission's computer server room.

The discrepancy between the number of helicopters deployed to the National Assembly and the records from the command center is also under investigation. According to materials submitted by Democratic Party lawmaker Baek Seung-ah to the Defense Ministry in December 2024, 12 Black Hawk helicopters carried troops from the 707 Special Mission Battalion to the National Assembly. Kim emphasized that the command center materials he reviewed only recorded movements of about four helicopters.

Kim also stated that he received testimonies from various unit personnel that they did not use PRE due to upper-level orders. Through an analysis report he recently provided to reporters, he claimed that while some units conducted communications to check their communication status, there were no records of position reports.

If, as Kim's analysis suggests, there are communication records but no position report records, it is necessary to examine the operational status of both functions. It is essential to compare communication records with testimonies from personnel to determine whether there was an issue with the position reporting function or if they received orders not to use it.

In this regard, attorney Byeon Gyeong-sik from the law firm Ilro explained, "Deliberately bypassing or blocking the command and control system could be subject to charges of rebellion under military law (Article 5), insurrection under criminal law (Article 87), and violation of orders under military law (Article 47)." It is crucial to determine whether troops were operated without the upper command's control and whether this was linked to the purpose of disrupting the constitutional order.

By comparing the testimonies of communication personnel and field officers with operational guidelines and records, it can be determined whether there was a problem with the equipment or if it was a result of following separate orders.

Why Did the Defense Command Withhold Approval? Conflicting Routes for Initial and Follow-up Helicopters

The allegations of helicopters deviating from flight control are connected to how quickly troops were intended to be deployed to the National Assembly. The complaint states that the three helicopters transporting the initial troops from the 707 Special Mission Battalion did not follow the normal route requested by the Capital Defense Command. It also mentions that subsequent helicopters delayed their arrival at the National Assembly by adhering to route compliance requirements.

Kim claimed in a recent analysis report that Kim Hyun-tae, then commander of the 707 Special Mission Battalion, boarded the first helicopter that arrived, while subsequent troops took a different route. By comparing the flight instructions received by the initial and follow-up troops, it can be determined whether the route selection was based on the pilots' on-site judgment or the demands of superiors to expedite deployment.

The fact that the Defense Command withheld approval for entry into the Seoul airspace delayed the helicopter deployment, as noted in the responses from the aviation commander during the National Assembly session. Kim Se-woon, then commander of the Special Operations Aviation Group, stated in December 2024 at the National Assembly's Defense Committee that the Defense Command withheld approval for airspace entry, which caused the delay in deployment.

Kim Moon-sang, then operations officer of the Defense Command, testified during the trials of former martial law commander Park An-soo and former Defense Command commander Lee Jin-woo last April that the entry approval was withheld three times due to unclear flight purposes. He explained that after consulting with the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Army Headquarters, he received an explanation that approval was granted by the martial law commander, allowing entry. The first request came in at 10:49 PM, and it took over 40 minutes to receive approval. According to Kim Hyun-seok's record analysis, the helicopters began flying around 11:32 PM, approximately 43 minutes after the first approval request.

It is necessary to confirm what instructions were exchanged between the Special Forces command, which was deploying troops, the Defense Command, which controlled the Seoul airspace, and the Army Headquarters and martial law command involved in the approval process. For helicopters carrying troops to head to the National Assembly, not only the Special Forces' deployment order but also approval for entering the Seoul airspace would have been required.

There are also allegations that the order to block access to the National Assembly was communicated during the helicopter's movement. A report by SBS indicated that a Telegram chat from the 707 Special Mission Battalion included instructions from then-commander Kim Hyun-tae at 11:46 PM on the day of the martial law to block the main assembly hall and access doors. Kim responded to SBS that he received a call from former Special Forces commander Kwak Jong-geun while on the helicopter and left the directive in the chat.

By comparing when and through whom the flight instructions and National Assembly blockade orders were communicated, the connection between troop transport and the operation to deploy to the National Assembly can be clarified. It is also essential to determine what missions the pilots received and whose orders they followed during the route selection process.

The investigation headquarters plans to identify the contact information and current workplaces of the pilots and co-pilots before selecting individuals for investigation. The record list of the case involving then-aviation commander Kim Se-woon has been requested for review and copying from the Central District Court, but a response indicated that providing the materials would be difficult. The investigation headquarters also requested cooperation for reviewing and copying related case records from the insurrection special investigation team.





* This article has been translated by AI.