AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Court Upholds License Revocation for Doctor Convicted of DUI


The Seoul Administrative Court has ruled that the Health and Welfare Ministry's decision to revoke the medical license of a doctor convicted of driving under the influence without a license is lawful.
 
According to legal sources on November 16, the court's Administrative Division 12, led by Judge Kang Jae-won, ruled against the plaintiff, referred to as A, who sought to overturn the license revocation by the Minister of Health and Welfare.
 
A was sentenced to one year in prison, suspended for two years, for driving under the influence with a blood alcohol concentration of 0.121% in November 2023. This sentence was upheld.

The Ministry revoked A's medical license in July 2023, citing the amended medical law enacted in May 2023. This law stipulates that any physician receiving a prison sentence of one year or more, regardless of the crime, will have their license revoked.
 
A argued that this provision infringes on the freedom to pursue a profession and claimed that the license revocation based on this law was illegal.

However, the court dismissed A's claims, stating that the provision does not excessively restrict professional freedom. The court also rejected A's request for a constitutional review of the law.
 
The judges noted that limiting license revocation to cases involving medical-related crimes would not achieve the same legislative goals and would not ensure public trust in medical professionals.
 
Additionally, the court pointed out that the license revocation is temporary and that receiving a suspended sentence for a general crime still carries significant social stigma. They concluded that the public interest in maintaining trust in medical professionals outweighs the disadvantages of restricting their professional freedom.
 
A representative from the Seoul Administrative Court stated, "This is the first ruling to specifically assess the constitutionality of this provision in cases of medical license revocation under the amended medical law."




* This article has been translated by AI.