AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Lower Credit Scores Linked to Lower Interest Rates as Banks Experience Rate Inversion

Contrary to the common belief that lower credit scores lead to higher loan interest rates, major banks are increasingly reporting instances where the average interest rate for lower credit score ranges is lower than that of the adjacent higher range. This trend is attributed to banks evaluating not only external credit scores but also income, debt, and transaction history, along with differences in the products offered and borrower profiles across ranges.


According to the financial sector on November 17, a comparison of average interest rates for general credit loans across different credit score ranges from January to September this year among the five largest banks—KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, Woori, and NH Nonghyup—revealed a total of 20 cases of rate inversion. This marks an increase of approximately 2.9 times compared to 7 cases during the same period last year.


The data indicates that the average interest rate for lower credit score ranges is lower than that of the next higher range, although this does not refer to the number of loans executed for individual borrowers.


Typically, credit scores are considered a primary criterion for determining loan interest rates. However, the scores published by external credit evaluation companies (CBs) are not the sole determinant of the final loan conditions set by banks.


Banks comprehensively assess borrowers' income, occupation, existing loan amounts, and repayment capabilities through their internal credit evaluation systems. Even if an external credit score is somewhat low, borrowers with stable income or favorable debt structures may qualify for relatively lower interest rates. Preferential rates based on transaction history, such as salary transfers, also influence the final interest rates.


To supplement evaluations based on financial transaction history and credit scores, banks are also adopting or enhancing alternative credit evaluation models that utilize non-financial information such as communication data, utility payment histories, and consumption patterns. This aims to increase financial accessibility by identifying borrowers with repayment capabilities, even if they have limited financial transaction histories.


Preferential products for low-to-moderate credit borrowers and financially vulnerable groups can also impact average interest rates across ranges. If the proportion of products targeting low-income individuals and preferential products increases, the average interest rate for that credit score range may decrease.


A bank official stated, “In line with the government's push for inclusive finance, banks are expanding financial products that provide tangible benefits to low-to-moderate credit borrowers, moving away from a focus on high-credit customers. There is a trend to strengthen support for financially vulnerable groups through products that lower interest burdens or enhance loan accessibility.”


However, the inversion of average interest rates across ranges does not necessarily indicate an overall improvement in loan conditions for low-to-moderate credit borrowers. In ranges with fewer loan transactions or amounts, the average interest rate can vary significantly based on a few preferential products or the conditions of specific borrowers.


Rate inversion illustrates that credit scores alone cannot adequately explain loan interest rates. To assess whether the actual financial burden has decreased, it is essential to examine the interest rates across ranges along with the volume of loans issued, product composition, and preferential conditions.





* This article has been translated by AI.