AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

SustainBest: Six of Ten Companies Sanctioned for Collusion Have Compliance Programs

 
Recently, it was revealed that six out of ten companies sanctioned for collusion over the past four years have implemented fair trade compliance programs (CP). The adoption rate was more than twice that of companies in the same industry with no history of sanctions.
 
According to the '2026 Second Half ESG Evaluation Results' released by the ESG evaluation agency SustainBest on November 17, a total of 125 collusion sanctions occurred among 94 domestic companies from 2023 to 2026.
 
SustainBest analyzed the status of fair trade management systems among the top 12 industries with the highest number of collusion sanctions out of 37 total industries. The sectors included construction, food and beverage, tobacco, durable consumer goods, clothing, and telecommunications services, with 79 out of 332 companies in these sectors having a history of collusion sanctions.
 
As of the second half of this year, the adoption rate of CP among sanctioned companies was recorded at 58.2%. This is double the rate of companies in the same industry with no history of sanctions (28.9%) and three times that of companies in industries without any collusion sanctions (19.4%). This gap in adoption rates has been maintained since 2023.
 
CP is an internal control system that companies operate to voluntarily comply with fair trade-related laws. It was introduced in 2001, requiring companies to designate compliance managers and implement employee training and internal monitoring systems.
 
Similar results were observed in the certification of compliance and anti-corruption management systems. The certification rate among sanctioned companies was 35.4%, which is 2.9 times higher than that of non-sanctioned companies (12.3%). The certification rate for sanctioned companies increased from 24.5% last year to 35.4% this year, a rise of 10.9 percentage points.
 
The proportion of companies that established fair trade principles was also higher among sanctioned companies, at 96.2%, compared to 82.2% for non-sanctioned companies, a difference of 14.0 percentage points. This gap has exceeded 12 percentage points annually over the past four years.
 
This indicates that simply having a compliance management system does not necessarily mean that a company is at risk of collusion. However, it is possible that companies have strengthened their internal control systems after being sanctioned, meaning that the mere introduction of such systems does not imply an increased risk of collusion.
 
The Fair Trade Commission evaluates the level of CP operation and assigns ratings, providing benefits such as reduced fines and exemptions from official investigations to exemplary companies. In April, it also announced plans to mandate the introduction and operation of CP for companies that repeatedly engage in collusion.
 
Ryu Young-jae, chairman of SustainBest, stated, "The fact that companies with a history of collusion have the highest rates of CP adoption and ethical management certification shows a gap between having the system and actual compliance management."
 
He added, "The introduction of CP should not be regarded as an achievement of compliance management. Companies must demonstrate the effectiveness of the system through actual prevention of violations and control outcomes, and the government should limit reductions in fines based on CP to cases where operational effectiveness has been verified."
 
Meanwhile, SustainBest analyzed the ESG management levels of 1,328 domestic listed and unlisted companies in this evaluation. This included 743 companies listed on the KOSPI, 340 on the KOSDAQ, and 245 unlisted companies.
 
The evaluation results showed that 160 companies received the highest AA rating, accounting for 12.0% of the total. There were 280 companies rated A (21.1%) and 362 rated BB (27.3%). SustainBest selected 100 listed companies that achieved excellent results across all areas of environment (E), social (S), and governance (G) as the '2026 Second Half ESG Best Companies.' Among companies with assets exceeding 2 trillion won, HK inno.N, Korea Aerospace Industries, and LG Uplus ranked in the top three. In the category of companies with assets between 500 billion and 2 trillion won, Colmar Holdings and A.P.R. ranked high, while M&C Solutions and POSCO M-Tech led among companies with assets below 500 billion won.
 
Additionally, the list of under-distributing companies, which compares the capacity for dividend payments with actual dividend levels, includes SK Bioscience, Mirae Asset Life, Hanwha Life, Krafton, Silicon Two, and Hugel.




* This article has been translated by AI.