AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Analysis of Commission Revenue Among Top 5 Securities Firms Reveals Distinct Strategies

The performance of securities firms in the third quarter showed a slowdown, but the differences in their revenue-generating strategies were clear. Korea Investment & Securities saw its mergers and acquisitions (M&A) commissions nearly double over the past year. Mirae Asset Securities excelled in brokerage and asset management (WM), while NH Investment & Securities stood out in the debt guarantee sector.


According to the Financial Supervisory Service's electronic disclosure system on November 17, the cumulative commission revenue for the top five securities firms—Korea Investment & Securities, Mirae Asset Securities, NH Investment & Securities, Samsung Securities, and Kiwoom Securities—varied significantly by business segment in the third quarter of this year.


Korea Investment & Securities demonstrated strength in the M&A sector. From January to September, the cumulative M&A commission reached 221.2 billion won, a 16.9% increase compared to the same period last year. Notably, in the third quarter, it recorded 101.6 billion won, marking a 99.1% surge from the same period last year. The cumulative underwriting and advisory fees for Korea Investment & Securities totaled 79.3 billion won, while guarantee fees amounted to 130.9 billion won. However, the company stated that it is difficult to disclose specific details regarding the size of individual transaction fees due to contractual and transaction-related matters. A representative from Korea Investment & Securities explained, "It is challenging to specify the individual transactions that contributed to M&A-related revenue or the size of fees for each transaction due to contractual obligations."


Kiwoom Securities also saw a significant increase in financial advisory-related fees. The cumulative M&A commission for the third quarter reached 78.7 billion won, a 97.2% increase compared to the same period last year. The third-quarter commission was 43.6 billion won, which is 5.6 times higher than the 7.8 billion won recorded during the same period last year. A representative from Kiwoom Securities stated, "The M&A commission can be viewed as part of our financial advisory fees (loan brokerage fees)," adding that specific transactions are difficult to disclose.


NH Investment & Securities made its mark in the debt guarantee sector. The cumulative debt guarantee fees for the third quarter reached 244.3 billion won, significantly surpassing the underwriting and advisory fees of 47.4 billion won and M&A fees of 16.1 billion won. Although the cumulative debt guarantee fees decreased by 9.2% compared to the same period last year, they increased by 24.9% in the third quarter to 87.1 billion won compared to the same period last year.


In the retail sector, Mirae Asset Securities stood out. The cumulative brokerage fees for the third quarter reached 1.4156 trillion won, while WM fees totaled 367.1 billion won. Although brokerage fees in the third quarter decreased by 47.2% compared to the previous quarter, WM fees only saw a 5.6% decline.


Samsung Securities secured revenue from financial product sales and underwriting and advisory services. The cumulative financial product sales revenue for the third quarter reached 275.4 billion won, while underwriting and advisory fees amounted to 244.2 billion won. The third-quarter underwriting and advisory fees decreased by 9.7% compared to the previous quarter, which was a smaller decline than the 46.2% drop in pure brokerage fees.


A representative from the securities industry noted, "Given the volatility of brokerage revenue depending on market conditions, it is crucial to secure stable commission revenue from various businesses such as WM and IB. In the future, not only the scale of net profit but also the competitiveness of revenue sources will be key factors determining the performance of securities firms."





* This article has been translated by AI.