AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Special Counsel Law Approved Amid Discussions on Dismissal of Lee Jae-myung's Cases


The special counsel law was approved at the State Council, reigniting discussions about the possibility of dismissing charges in three criminal trials involving President Lee Jae-myung before their first trial verdicts. During the National Assembly review process, a provision allowing the special counsel to decide on maintaining charges for existing cases was omitted. The key issue is whether the Prosecutor's Office handling the trial will continue to maintain charges if evidence tampering or coercion of testimony is revealed during the special counsel's investigation.

On November 17, the State Council, chaired by Prime Minister Han Dong-hoon, approved the special counsel law that passed the National Assembly on November 6. The law will take effect from the day it is promulgated after the President's approval. The special counsel will investigate allegations that state agencies, including the prosecution, the National Intelligence Service, and the Board of Audit and Inspection, manipulated evidence or coerced testimony during the investigation and prosecution processes.

Among the 12 items under investigation by the special counsel, six are related to President Lee. The allegations regarding Daejang-dong development and the sponsorship funds for Seongnam FC are included as separate items in the special counsel law, but they have been consolidated into one trial in court. The witness tampering case is in the appeals stage, while the case related to violations of the Public Official Election Act due to statements regarding Daejang-dong and Baekhyeon-dong is pending at the Supreme Court remand trial. In both cases, while the special counsel can investigate the circumstances of the prosecution and charges, the window for dismissing charges has passed.

The focus on the three trials for discussions on charge dismissal is due to the trial level. According to Article 255 of the Criminal Procedure Act, prosecutors can dismiss charges before the first trial verdict is announced. Among the five trials involving President Lee, the cases concerning the Daejang-dong, Wirye, and Baekhyeon-dong development allegations, the Ssangbangwool North Korea remittance case, and the Gyeonggi Province corporate card misuse case are still before the first trial verdict.

Even for the three cases remaining at the first trial level, revealing any illegality in the special counsel's investigation does not automatically conclude the trials. For instance, if the special counsel confirms the coercion of specific testimony, the Prosecutor's Office must assess whether that testimony supports any charges and whether the remaining evidence can substantiate the allegations. The facts and evidence that served as the basis for charges in the consolidated trials regarding Daejang-dong development and Seongnam FC sponsorship funds are different.

In this process, the roles of the Minister of Justice and the Prosecutor General diverge. The entity responsible for indicating the intent to dismiss charges in court is the prosecutor assigned to the case. When the Minister of Justice exercises authority over a specific case, they must direct the Prosecutor General according to the Prosecutor's Office Act. If the Minister intends to direct the dismissal of charges in President Lee's case, they cannot directly instruct the assigned prosecutor and must go through the Prosecutor General. This context has led to heightened interest in the appointments of the next minister and prosecutor general regarding how the Prosecutor's Office will decide after the special counsel's investigation results are released.

Lee Yong-cheol, the candidate for Minister of Justice, stated that he would focus on uncovering the truth regarding the dismissal of charges and would follow the law and principles afterward. He refrained from making a judgment on whether to direct the dismissal. During the upcoming confirmation hearing, the issue of when specific case direction is deemed necessary in relation to the special counsel's investigation results may become a point of contention.

Opinions also differ on the impact of the special counsel's investigation on existing trials.

Kim Sung-hwa, the floor leader of the Democratic Party, stated during a National Assembly briefing that "to ensure the purpose of the special counsel is not undermined, we have deleted not only the provisions related to charge dismissal but also the demands for transferring existing cases."

Conversely, former Seoul Central District Prosecutor Song Kyung-ho, who oversaw investigations related to President Lee, along with former Suwon District Prosecutors Hong Seung-wook, Kim Yoo-cheol, and Shin Bong-soo, asserted in a joint statement that the special counsel law aims to achieve "the dismissal of charges or equivalent outcomes for specific targets, including the sitting president."




* This article has been translated by AI.