On the 19th, the Supreme Court's full bench will deliver a ruling on the appeal of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo regarding the charge of 'engaging in important duties related to insurrection' in connection with the December 3 Martial Law. The court will determine the extent of responsibility that can be assigned to the Prime Minister, the 'number two' in the executive branch.
In the lead-up to this ruling, a curious scene unfolded.
On the 17th, a Cabinet meeting was held to deliberate and decide on the 'Special Prosecutor Law for Manipulated Indictments.' This meeting was chaired by Prime Minister Han Sung-sook while President Lee Jae-myung was on an overseas trip. Of the twelve cases under investigation by the special prosecutor, six are related to incidents for which President Lee has been indicted and is currently on trial. Controversy over conflicts of interest and constitutionality is heating up.
Han Duck-soo and Han Sung-sook. Although their situations differ, the question posed to both Prime Ministers remains the same.
“Can you say 'no' to the President?”
The appellate court for the Han Duck-soo case took a serious view of the responsibilities of the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister is the President's primary advisor and the second-in-command of the executive branch, serving to ensure that the President's powers are exercised constitutionally and legally, while also checking and controlling any misuse of authority.
There is a reason the Constitution does not allow the President to appoint the Prime Minister at will, requiring approval from the National Assembly. In the Cabinet meeting, the President serves as the chair, while the Prime Minister is the vice chair. Major national issues, such as legislation and martial law, are placed under the 'deliberation' of the Cabinet to prevent unilateral decisions by the President.
What was the Cabinet meeting led by Prime Minister Han Sung-sook like on the 17th? If the stance is that “since the National Assembly has passed it, it can be promulgated,” then there is no reason for the Cabinet to exist. Especially when it involves a special prosecutor reviewing the investigation and indictment processes of a case involving the sitting President, it should have been more stringent. Questions should have been raised about whether the President's authority to appoint the special prosecutor is appropriate and whether there are sufficient measures to avoid conflicts of interest.
Moreover, this special prosecutor law is not a typical national issue. It is a law that revisits a significant portion of the investigation and indictment processes of a case in which the sitting President is a defendant. In such circumstances, the Cabinet should have more rigorously separated the President's interests from the nation's interests.
The issue of conflicts of interest does not disappear simply because the President is absent. Rather, the Prime Minister, who presides over the meeting in the President's absence, should have asked, “Is this law favorable to the President personally?” rather than “Is this law acceptable if we remove the President's name?” If the Cabinet meeting is not a place to confirm the President's will but rather to affirm constitutional boundaries, this is even more critical. When the interests of those in power overlap with the principles of the state, the Prime Minister's role is not merely to add a vote in favor but to draw a line between the two.
The lessons from the December 3 Martial Law are found here. When high-ranking officials begin to accept the President's judgments without question, the checks and balances become mere formalities. The moment the Cabinet transforms into a place that legitimizes the President's decisions procedurally, 'deliberation' becomes 'endorsement.'
If you are an aide to the President, you should faithfully execute the President's will. However, the Prime Minister is different. The Prime Minister is a 'constitutional institution.' Just because they are part of the same government as the President does not mean their judgments should align. The position of vice chair of the Cabinet was not given to simply follow the President's lead when they accelerate. The Prime Minister should be the first to apply the brakes when the President is heading in the wrong direction.
The ruling on Han Duck-soo on the 19th should not end as a judgment directed solely at past administrations. Current Cabinet members, including Prime Minister Han Sung-sook, must also reflect on it.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.