AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Prosecution's Suspension of Charges Against Bloggers Promoting EVE Pain Reliever Canceled


The Constitutional Court has canceled the prosecution's suspension of charges against bloggers who promoted the Japanese pain reliever EVE, which contains banned narcotic ingredients. The court stated that it is difficult to conclude that there was intent to advertise narcotics, as it was hard to know at the time of the advertisement that the product contained psychoactive substances.

According to the official gazette on the 18th, the Constitutional Court unanimously canceled four suspensions of charges issued by prosecutors from the Suwon District Prosecutor's Office against four individuals, including A, on October 22.

From 2022 to 2024, A and others posted articles on Naver Blog introducing reviews and purchasing methods for the EVE pain reliever. Investigations revealed that they promoted the product with titles like "I bought EVE pain reliever in Japan" and provided information on where to purchase it. They were found to have written these articles in exchange for receiving the product for free as part of a marketing company's experience group.

The prosecution believed that they posted advertisements for the purpose of selling narcotics and issued suspensions of charges for violations of the Narcotics Control Act. A suspension of charges is a decision not to proceed to trial despite acknowledging the criminal charges, considering various circumstances such as the motive and context of the crime.

However, A and others contested the decision, claiming they were unaware that the product contained narcotic ingredients at the time of the advertisement. Many EVE products sold in Japan contain allylisopropylacetylurea, a substance classified as a psychoactive drug in South Korea, making its importation illegal.

The Constitutional Court noted the difference in timing between when the advertisement was posted and when the narcotic ingredients of the product became known. The period from 2022 to 2024, when they posted on their blogs, was before the fact that EVE contained psychoactive substances was widely reported in the media. The Customs Service's ban on importation was reported in the media in April 2025.

The court concluded that it would have been difficult to easily ascertain the presence of the substance through internet searches at that time. It also considered that they wrote promotional articles after receiving the product as part of an experience group. The court determined that it is unlikely that the authors were aware of the existence of narcotic ingredients while advertising.

The court stated, "There is insufficient evidence to recognize that the claimants were aware that the product contained psychoactive substances," and pointed out that the prosecution concluded there was intent to violate the Narcotics Control Act without supplementary investigations into related facts.

Furthermore, the court found that there was arbitrary evidence judgment, insufficient investigation, and a misunderstanding of legal principles in the prosecution's decision, determining that the rights to equality and the pursuit of happiness of A and others were violated.




* This article has been translated by AI.