AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

[Shenzhen APEC] South Korea Faces 'Dialogue Dilemma' Ahead of US-China-Russia Talks

As the first-ever summit between the United States, China, and Russia approaches, discussions about North Korean leader Kim Jong-un's visit to China and the possibility of contact between US and North Korean leaders have emerged, making the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen a pivotal moment for the Korean Peninsula's situation. While the three nations are increasingly likely to discuss security issues on the peninsula, there are concerns that South Korea, as a key party, may be excluded from discussions on freezing North Korea's nuclear program or easing sanctions.


According to the presidential office on the 18th, President Lee Jae-myung held a summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping. In his opening remarks, President Lee emphasized that for the strategic cooperative partnership between South Korea and China to develop, peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula must be ensured, proposing that the two countries work together to usher in an era of 'peaceful coexistence.' President Xi expressed his intention to strengthen communication and coordination with South Korea.


This meeting signifies a reaffirmation of the two countries' commitment to cooperation for peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula. Earlier, Foreign Minister Park Jin requested China's role in facilitating North Korea's return to dialogue during a meeting with Wang Yi, head of the Chinese Communist Party's Central Foreign Affairs Commission and Foreign Minister, in Beijing on the 13th. Minister Wang stated that China's policy on the Korean Peninsula remains unchanged and that it will continue to play a constructive role for peace and stability.


However, despite the agreement between the two leaders on the overarching principle of peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula, it remains to be seen how much of South Korea's specific stance on North Korea's nuclear program and sanctions has been communicated to China. Particularly, if the issue of the Korean Peninsula arises during the US-China-Russia summit scheduled for the 19th, how well China reflects South Korea's interests will likely serve as a benchmark for assessing the practical outcomes of the Korea-China summit.


President Xi, US President Donald Trump, and Russian President Vladimir Putin are set to hold their first trilateral summit in Shenzhen on the 19th. With nuclear disarmament and the Iran issue among the main agenda items, there is a significant possibility that discussions on the Korean Peninsula, including freezing North Korea's nuclear program and sanctions, will also be included.


Concerns are heightened as Russia has publicly denied the legitimacy of sanctions against North Korea ahead of the US-China-Russia summit. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov claimed on the 17th at the East Asia Summit (EAS) in Manila that the main reason for the increasing potential for conflict on the Korean Peninsula is the sanctions and military pressure on North Korea.


In a press conference following the meeting, he stated that the purpose of the South Korea-US-Japan joint exercises is to deter North Korea and maintain sanctions, asserting, 'For us, such sanctions no longer exist.' Given that Russia participated in the adoption of UN Security Council sanctions against North Korea, its outright denial of the sanctions regime raises concerns that the focus of the US-China-Russia summit may shift from responding to the North Korean nuclear threat to easing sanctions and alleviating military pressure.


Additionally, President Trump indicated on the 16th that he might meet with Kim Jong-un in China, introducing the 'Kim Jong-un variable.' On the 17th, he reiterated that Kim wants to come to China, suggesting the possibility of a meeting. He mentioned that whether Kim visits China depends on President Xi, raising the prospect of China's mediation. The Kremlin also stated that if Kim attends the APEC summit, he could meet with President Putin.


With the Korea-China summit concluded, the government's diplomatic task now shifts to follow-up coordination after the US-China-Russia summit. If the Korean Peninsula issue is discussed at the trilateral meeting, there are calls to activate communication channels to share results immediately with the US and China, and to assess the impact of discussions on freezing nuclear programs and easing sanctions on South Korea's denuclearization principles and the South Korea-US alliance. In preparation for the potential realization of US-North Korea contact, there are suggestions to pre-coordinate negotiation agendas between South Korea and the US and to develop follow-up scenarios that connect this to inter-Korean dialogue or a quadrilateral dialogue involving South Korea, North Korea, China, and the US.


A representative from the Korea Institute for National Unification stated in a conversation with Aju Economy that while the US-China-Russia summit faces numerous pressing issues among the three countries and lacks sufficient prior practical consultations, the likelihood of reaching substantial decisions regarding the Korean Peninsula issue is low. However, he noted that if South Korea raises the issue, it could call for China's active role in resolving the North Korean nuclear problem. He emphasized the need to utilize a multilateral framework or methods for China to persuade North Korea to cooperate in resolving the nuclear issue.





* This article has been translated by AI.