AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

[Shenzhen APEC] Takaiichi Shinsuke shakes hands with Xi Jinping for 15 seconds and talks with Putin for 30 minutes... 'Wedge diplomacy' ahead of US-China-Russia summit


Japanese Prime Minister Takaiichi Sanae shook hands with Chinese President Xi Jinping for about 15 seconds and spoke with Russian President Vladimir Putin for approximately 30 minutes during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit that opened in Shenzhen, China, on November 18. This marked the first face-to-face conversation between a Japanese leader and President Putin since Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Although Takaiichi engaged with the leaders of China and Russia just a day before the first-ever US-China-Russia summit, significant differences remain on key issues with Russia, and no formal meeting schedule has been set with China, leaving the potential for substantial improvement in relations uncertain.
 

First face-to-face meeting between Japan and Russia in seven years 

The conversation between Prime Minister Takaiichi and President Putin took place immediately after the APEC welcome dinner. The meeting was initiated by the Japanese side, and both parties agreed to continue communication at various levels. This was also the first face-to-face meeting between leaders since former Prime Minister Abe Shinzo in 2019.

During the meeting, Takaiichi demanded the immediate release of a Hokkaido Shimbun journalist who was detained on espionage charges by Russian authorities last October. Although he raised the issue again during a foreign ministers' meeting at the end of October without any progress, he decided to address it directly as the leader. According to the Nikkei, Takaiichi also appeared to urge the withdrawal of Russia's recent action that effectively stripped the management rights of Japan Tobacco's (JT) local subsidiary by presidential decree.

Since President Putin's visit to the disputed southern Kuril Islands (known as the Northern Territories in Japan) in August, Russia has increased pressure on Japan through the detention of the journalist and the stripping of JT's management rights. Russia maintains that Japan is responsible for the deterioration of Russia-Japan relations due to sanctions imposed after the invasion of Ukraine, insisting that dialogue can only resume if Japan withdraws its 'unfriendly policies'.

Despite the ongoing sanctions against Russia, analysts suggest that Russia's willingness to engage in this dialogue reflects its own calculations. The Nikkei forecasts that Russia may use these issues as leverage to demand a policy shift from Japan, including the lifting of sanctions. Additionally, by responding to Japan's request for dialogue without concessions, Russia can project an image of Japan seeking improved relations to the international community.

Japan, which aligns its sanctions against Russia and support for Ukraine with the United States and Europe, has limited room for independent concessions. The Japanese government views the significance of this dialogue as restoring communication channels rather than achieving immediate results. According to the Yomiuri Shimbun, a Foreign Ministry official explained that the goal is to establish communication lines to address issues between the two countries. The limitations of communication have become evident, as it took nearly two weeks for a consular visit to the detained journalist, approved through diplomatic channels, to actually occur. The Japanese government hopes that resuming communication between leaders will help prevent accidental military clashes and resolve ongoing issues.
 

Uncertain Japan-China summit

While a dialogue has been established with Russia, there are no signs of a summit with China during Takaiichi's first visit since taking office. This contrasts with President Xi's plans to hold individual meetings with leaders attending the APEC summit. If the meeting ultimately does not take place, it would break the pattern of Japan-China summits held annually since 2022 during APEC. The two countries have not met at the leader or ministerial level since Takaiichi mentioned the possibility of exercising collective self-defense in response to a Taiwan contingency in a parliamentary response last November.

The inability to even hold a meeting stems from the unresolved differences between the two countries regarding the Taiwan contingency response. China has demanded that Takaiichi correct his remarks and insists that Japan must take the initiative to normalize relations. This places the onus on Japan while China appears to be waiting patiently. The Asahi Shimbun analyzes that China is currently maintaining stable relations with the US and Russia and feels no need to compromise economically with Japan, which contributes to its relaxed stance.

Japan also finds it difficult to back down. Previous Japanese governments have maintained a strategy of ambiguity regarding whether a Taiwan contingency would warrant the exercise of collective self-defense, stating that it would depend on individual circumstances. The Takaiichi administration has attempted to clarify that its existing position has not changed in response to China's strong backlash, but China has not accepted this. However, retracting the response could limit Japan's actions in a Taiwan contingency. Additionally, with Takaiichi seeking re-election in the ruling Liberal Democratic Party's presidential election next autumn, it becomes even more challenging to make concessions that could provoke backlash from conservative factions. A government official stated, "The resolution is not that simple."

Given the difficulty of expecting a formal summit, opinions within the Japanese government were divided on how to approach the handshake with Xi. According to the Yomiuri, one official suggested that while a formal meeting may be difficult, informal conversations could lead to progress, advocating for proactive engagement. Conversely, there were cautious voices warning that approaching too hastily could backfire, given Xi's firm stance. Ultimately, Takaiichi smiled and initiated conversation during the approximately 15-second handshake, but Xi did not respond.

Some within the government have assessed that while it was not a formal meeting, the handshake between the leaders represents a step forward. However, communication channels with China are increasingly narrowing. Former Prime Minister Abe Shinzo, who was also considered a hardliner toward China, used former Prime Minister Fukuda Yasuo as a bridge for communication, but Fukuda passed away last month. As a Foreign Ministry official noted, "Improving relations takes years," and there is a prevailing outlook that Japan will have to focus on strengthening ties with allies such as the US for the time being.

Meanwhile, a historic first US-China-Russia summit is set to take place on the afternoon of November 19. Japan is coordinating a phone consultation between Takaiichi and President Trump following the summit, aiming to showcase close US-Japan ties by receiving immediate updates on the meeting's outcomes.

At the same time, the Yomiuri analyzes that Japan has grown increasingly aware of the need to independently rebuild relations with China and Russia, rather than relying solely on the US. Concerns have been raised that China and Russia may leverage their historical status as allies against Japan during World War II to draw the US into their orbit. The more Japan confronts China and Russia, the greater the motivation for them to involve the US in pressuring Japan. The Japanese government is calculating that by directly addressing these relations, it can reduce that motivation, with a senior government official stating that this approach "drives a wedge into the US-China-Russia engagement."





* This article has been translated by AI.