The financial authorities have initiated improvements to reduce the insurance premium burden on health insurance subscribers and enhance the convenience of claims. However, existing subscribers must weigh the discounts against reduced coverage, and the digitization of claims faces challenges in increasing participation from local clinics and pharmacies. Experts point out that for the improvements to translate into tangible benefits for consumers, incentives must be provided to engage both subscribers and medical institutions.
On November 19, the Financial Services Commission held a meeting to review health insurance and announced that subscribers of the first and second generations of health insurance without re-enrollment conditions would receive a 50% discount on premiums for three years if they switch to the fifth-generation product starting November 23. This measure aims to alleviate the high premium burden and encourage the transition to the fifth-generation product.
The Financial Services Commission estimates that applying the transition discount for a woman in her 60s would reduce the monthly premium for first-generation subscribers from 176,982 won (KRW) to 21,620 won (KRW), a decrease of 87.8%. For second-generation subscribers, the premium would drop from 126,773 won (KRW) to 21,620 won (KRW), a reduction of 82.9%.
The issue is that while premiums decrease, the coverage that subscribers previously enjoyed also diminishes. Depending on the timing of enrollment and the type of product, first and second-generation health insurance often has no deductible or a deductible rate of 10-20%. Transitioning to the fifth generation may increase out-of-pocket expenses for medical services. Some items previously covered, such as physical therapy for musculoskeletal conditions, extracorporeal shock wave therapy, and certain non-covered injections, will be excluded from coverage in the fifth generation. The out-of-pocket rate for non-severe non-covered items will rise to 50%, and the compensation limit will decrease to 10 million won (KRW) annually.
Given the changes in the coverage structure, the insurance industry views it as challenging to attract existing subscribers solely through premium discounts. Subscribers looking to reduce their premium burden may have already moved to third and fourth-generation products, and those maintaining first and second generations are less likely to give up their existing broad coverage.
So far, sales of fifth-generation health insurance have primarily focused on new subscriptions. Within about five months of its launch, approximately 400,000 contracts have been made, with the proportion of contracts voluntarily transitioned from the first to fourth generations estimated at around 15%. The impact of the transition discount starting on November 23 on existing subscribers' choices will be crucial.
An industry insider stated, “It is questionable whether the transition discount for the fifth generation will provide sufficient incentives for consumers who wish to maintain their existing contracts in anticipation of increased medical usage in the future.”
Choosing a discount option that lowers premiums while maintaining existing contracts also requires accepting reduced coverage. This includes excluding coverage for physical therapy for musculoskeletal conditions, non-covered injections, and non-covered MRI/MRA, or increasing the deductible rate. If all three options are applied, premiums can be reduced by about 37% for first-generation and about 27% for second-generation subscribers, but even if existing contracts are maintained, the coverage details will change, necessitating careful consideration of the pros and cons of medical usage.
The digitization of health insurance claims, which the financial authorities are promoting alongside reducing premium burdens, also faces challenges. As of November 18, the linkage rate of the health insurance claims digitization system, Health Insurance 24, was 54.2%. The linkage rate for clinics and pharmacies was also 53.4%, indicating that nearly half are still not connected to the system.
If local clinics and pharmacies, which consumers frequently use, are not linked, it will be difficult to utilize the simplified claims process through Health Insurance 24 even after treatment. If the linkage rate does not improve, the service to help recover unclaimed health insurance benefits, which the authorities plan to introduce early next year, may also be limited in effectiveness. This is because it is challenging to verify treatment histories from unlinked medical institutions, which hampers support for insurance benefit guidance and simplified claims.
The lack of incentives for medical institutions to participate is cited as a reason for the delay in linkage. Clinics that do not experience high demand for health insurance claims do not feel a significant need for system implementation, and the perceived effectiveness of the incentives provided by the government is also limited.
Currently, linked medical institutions receive benefits such as a 3-5% discount on general insurance premiums like medical malpractice and fire insurance, and a 0.2 percentage point reduction in guarantee fees for loans guaranteed by the Credit Guarantee Fund for five years. However, for clinics that do not utilize guaranteed loans, the reduction in guarantee fees is meaningless, and the discount on premiums varies depending on the type of product and premium size.
The passive attitude of electronic medical record (EMR) companies is also a hurdle. Improvements to EMR software are necessary for linkage with Health Insurance 24, but some companies are reportedly hesitant to participate due to the costs and personnel burdens associated with system development, application for each medical institution, training, and maintenance. To broaden the scope of claims digitization, participation from medical institutions and expedited linkage efforts from EMR companies are essential.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.