AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Internal Transactions Remain Around 280 Trillion Won, Focused on Family-Controlled Companies

The amount of internal transactions among domestic affiliates of large business groups has remained around 280 trillion won (KRW) over the past four years. Although the proportion of internal transactions relative to sales has decreased, the trend of transactions concentrating in companies with high ownership stakes held by the controlling families continues.


According to the Fair Trade Commission's "Analysis of Internal Transaction Status of Publicly Disclosed Business Groups in 2026" released on the 19th, the internal transaction amount among domestic affiliates last year was recorded at 277.4 trillion won (KRW). This represents an increase of 59.4 trillion won (KRW), or 27.2%, compared to 218 trillion won (KRW) in 2021.


After a sharp increase to 275.1 trillion won (KRW) in 2022, the internal transaction amounts were 277.9 trillion won (KRW) in 2023, 281.2 trillion won (KRW) in 2024, and 277.4 trillion won (KRW) last year. Essentially, the figures have remained similar over the past four years.


In contrast, the proportion of internal transactions fell for two consecutive years, from 12.8% in 2023 to 12.3% in 2024, and then to 11.5% last year. The Fair Trade Commission analyzed that while the internal transaction amounts remained stable during the same period, the total sales of business groups increased by approximately 11%, from 2,164 trillion won (KRW) to 2,403 trillion won (KRW).


More noteworthy than the overall transaction scale is the concentration of transactions. Last year, the internal transaction amount of the top 10 business groups in the country was about 185 trillion won (KRW), accounting for 66.7% of the total. Although this was an 8 trillion won (KRW) decrease from the previous year, two-thirds of the domestic affiliate transaction amounts originated from these top 10 groups.


The relationship between the ownership stake of the controlling family and the proportion of internal transactions is also evident. Last year, companies with an ownership stake of over 20% held by the controlling family had an internal transaction proportion of 9.6%, while those with over 30% was 11.5%, over 50% was 17.8%, and 100% was 22.8%.


The internal transaction proportion of companies with 100% ownership by the controlling family rose from 23.7% in 2021 to 27.7% in 2022, before dropping to 22.8% last year. Although the proportion has decreased, the trend of higher dependency on internal transactions in companies with higher ownership stakes has persisted over the past five years.


The concentration phenomenon is also confirmed in the transaction status of companies subject to profit extraction regulations. Among the 831 analyzed companies with over 20% ownership by the controlling family and subsidiaries where the company holds more than 50% of the shares, the internal transaction amount last year was 38.6 trillion won (KRW), an increase of 1.2 trillion won (KRW) from the previous year. The overall internal transaction proportion was 11.0%, but the proportion for regulated companies belonging to the top 10 groups was 16.1%, more than double that of other groups (7.3%).


The reliance on negotiated contracts also remains high. Of the 38.6 trillion won (KRW) in internal transactions for companies subject to profit extraction regulations last year, 35.5 trillion won (KRW), or 92.0%, were conducted through negotiated contracts. This figure is an increase of 3.8 percentage points from the previous year (88.2%). The proportion of negotiated contracts was recorded at 90.8% and 89.6% in 2022 and 2023, respectively, maintaining a high level around 90% over the past four years.


While a high proportion of internal transactions or negotiated contracts does not immediately indicate unfair favoritism, the continued concentration of transactions in specific ownership structures since the expansion of profit extraction regulations at the end of 2021 highlights the need for monitoring regarding transaction conditions and the provision of economic benefits.


The challenge lies in proving whether these transactions constitute unfair support or profit extraction. Ultimately, enhancing the legal criteria for determining unfair internal transactions and the effectiveness of sanctions is seen as a critical task.


Park Sang-in, a professor at Seoul National University’s Graduate School of Public Administration, stated, "The Fair Trade Commission has investigated and sanctioned unfair internal transactions over the past decade, but many cases have been overturned in court. The current legal provisions and judicial precedents do not align with the intent of the law to regulate unfair internal transactions, resulting in reduced effectiveness."


He added, "Requiring proof of unfairness based on normal pricing, despite the difficulty in determining it, is a representative example. The law should be amended to allow for the assessment of illegality in line with regulatory objectives, such as restricting transaction opportunities for external competitors or unfairly benefiting the controlling family."





* This article has been translated by AI.