AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Nuclear Talks Among US, China, and Russia: Who Designs Peace on the Korean Peninsula?


Nuclear weapons are the most powerful weapons created by humanity. At the same time, they are the most tragic invention that proves humans can destroy their own civilization. They represent a victory of science but a defeat of human reason. Countries that possess nuclear weapons can become great powers, but a world that cannot eliminate nuclear weapons can never be a safe civilized society.

On November 19, 2026, a historic scene unfolded in Shenzhen, China. U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin sat together. The leaders of three nuclear-armed nations that influence the strategic balance of the world held an unprecedented trilateral summit and announced a joint declaration for peace.

The essence of the declaration was simple. There are no winners in a nuclear war, and nuclear war must never occur. The three countries agreed to engage in dialogue to reduce nuclear risks and prevent the proliferation of nuclear weapons.

This is a statement that seems obvious when considering the fate of humanity. However, the fact that the leaders of the world's three great powers jointly confirmed this principle is significant. It acknowledges a shared responsibility not to neglect the dangers of nuclear war.
 
"Developing Nuclear Weapons Late Violates International Order"... The Contradiction of the Non-Proliferation Treaty
The issue arises after the declaration. There is a deep chasm between the promise not to engage in nuclear war and the practical steps to reduce nuclear weapons. There is an even more daunting mountain range between the agreement to prevent proliferation and the task of dismantling the nuclear arsenals of countries that have already developed them.

At the center of that mountain range lies the Korean Peninsula.

The atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945 were the first demonstration of what nuclear weapons are. Cities were destroyed, and countless lives were lost. For the survivors, radiation damage and deep scars remained. World War II ended, but the fear of nuclear weapons did not.

During the Cold War, the United States and the Soviet Union competitively stockpiled nuclear weapons. The theory of nuclear deterrence, which posits that the ability to destroy the opponent actually deters war, became the central logic of international security. This is the so-called balance of terror.

However, the balance of terror is not the same as peace. It is an order built on the uneasy expectation that the opponent will not pull the trigger first. A miscalculation, a technical error, or a wrong judgment by a political leader could lead to an irreversible disaster.

To reduce these risks, the international community adopted the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) in 1968 and brought it into force in 1970. This treaty recognizes the United States, Russia, China, the United Kingdom, and France as nuclear-armed states while preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons to other countries and imposing an obligation on nuclear-armed states to engage in sincere negotiations for nuclear disarmament.

Herein lies the fundamental contradiction of the nuclear order. Countries that possess nuclear weapons are recognized as nuclear-armed states, while countries that seek to develop nuclear weapons late are deemed violators of the international order. This structure is understandable considering historical circumstances, but it cannot be justified indefinitely.

The ultimate goal of the NPT is not to perpetuate the privileges of existing nuclear-armed states but to move toward a world without nuclear weapons. If nuclear-armed states neglect their disarmament obligations while demanding denuclearization from other countries, it will be difficult to gain the trust of the international community.

The true value of the recent U.S.-China-Russia summit hinges on how much this contradiction can be resolved.

The three countries promised to engage in dialogue to prevent nuclear war and proliferation. However, the joint declaration did not include targets for reducing warheads, verification procedures, or specific negotiation timelines. While principles were confirmed, a blueprint for implementation was not presented.
 
North Korean Nuclear Issue and Korean Peninsula Denuclearization Not Specified in Joint Declaration

The North Korean nuclear issue is particularly noteworthy.

According to the Chinese announcement, the three leaders discussed international issues, including the Korean Peninsula. However, the joint declaration did not specify North Korean nuclear weapons or the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula. The agreement to engage in dialogue to prevent proliferation is entirely different from agreeing on North Korean denuclearization.

While this declaration could serve as a diplomatic opportunity for denuclearization on the Korean Peninsula, it does not itself promise the dismantling of North Korean nuclear weapons. This is the challenge that South Korean diplomacy must address.

How should this silence be interpreted?

It cannot be concluded that the three leaders ignored the North Korean nuclear issue. There is a possibility that the joint declaration contained only broad principles. However, it is also possible that they could not reach a specific agreement on denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula or did not align their positions enough to include it in the joint document.

The clear fact is that the North Korean nuclear issue remains unresolved.

North Korea declared its withdrawal from the NPT in 2003 and conducted its first nuclear test in 2006. Since then, it has continued to develop nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles through several tests. In 2022, it legalized its nuclear policy, defining nuclear power as a core means of national defense.

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported on the 18th that activities continue at North Korea's uranium enrichment facilities in Yongbyon and Kangson. Notably, additional expansion work at the existing enrichment facility in Yongbyon has been observed since mid-September, with completion noted by the end of October. The IAEA also reported signs of operation at the Yongbyon 5-megawatt reactor and the status of the operation of the light-water reactor. While there are limitations to on-site inspections, the international community's concerns about the expansion of North Korea's nuclear program are evident.

The North Korean nuclear issue can no longer be resolved by mere declarations. North Korea's fear that abandoning nuclear weapons would threaten its regime's security clashes directly with the concerns of South Korea and the international community that possessing nuclear weapons threatens regional safety.

If this dilemma is not resolved, denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula will remain merely a slogan.

The United States is an ally that provides extended deterrence to South Korea. China has significant economic and diplomatic influence over North Korea. Russia has also been strengthening its strategic relationship with North Korea. Therefore, it is difficult to expect a fundamental resolution to the North Korean nuclear issue without cooperation among the three countries.

However, the fate of the Korean Peninsula cannot be left solely to negotiations among the three great powers.

If a nuclear war were to occur on the Korean Peninsula, the first to be destroyed would be the lives of the Korean people. This includes the citizens of Seoul and Pyongyang, industrial facilities, cultural heritage, and the history of the nation built over many years. This is why the lives and safety of the residents of the Korean Peninsula must take precedence over the strategic interests of great powers.
 
Deterrence is a Means to Prevent War, Not the Ultimate Goal of Peace

South Korea must leverage this declaration as a new diplomatic opportunity.

First, it must maintain effective deterrence and crisis management capabilities based on its alliance with the United States. It should not ignore real security threats in the name of pursuing peace. However, military deterrence alone cannot resolve the nuclear issue. Deterrence is a means to prevent war, not the ultimate goal of peace.

At the same time, it must demand responsible roles from China and Russia. If the two countries jointly commit to preventing proliferation, they must also apply that principle to the North Korean nuclear issue. Their friendly relations with North Korea should not serve as a justification for tolerating nuclear proliferation.

Dialogue with North Korea must also not be abandoned. While maintaining the ultimate goal of denuclearization, it is necessary to negotiate a phased approach to halt nuclear tests and missile provocations, limit the production of nuclear materials, ensure international verification, and reduce military tensions. A phased approach does not mean legally recognizing North Korea's possession of nuclear weapons. It is a diplomatic method to reduce real risks while moving toward ultimate denuclearization.

Above all, nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation cannot be separated.

If the United States, China, and Russia continue to enhance their nuclear capabilities while demanding that North Korea abandon its nuclear weapons, their arguments will have limits. Conversely, North Korea's justification of its nuclear development based on the nuclear possession of great powers is also unacceptable. The danger of nuclear weapons does not disappear depending on which country possesses them.

Here, humanity faces a fundamental question.

Does science exist for humanity, or do humans become subordinate to the power of science?

Nuclear physics has unveiled the secrets of nature. Nuclear power has contributed to electricity production and advancements in medicine and industry. However, the same science can become a weapon that can destroy countless lives in an instant. Science itself is neither good nor evil. The morality and political judgment of those who wield that power determine the direction of civilization.

Albert Einstein deeply worried about the dangers of the nuclear age. He reminded us that the advancement of science and technology alone cannot guarantee humanity's safety. Today, as artificial intelligence and advanced military technology converge, that warning becomes even more urgent.

Eastern wisdom is no different. The "Tao Te Ching" emphasizes restraint and humility over the display of force. The "Analects" finds the foundation of politics in the trust of the people. The measure of a civilized nation is not how many nuclear weapons it possesses, but how much it can restrain that power.

The leaders of the United States, China, and Russia hold immense power to influence the global nuclear order. However, that power cannot exist above the lives of humanity. While nuclear weapons may symbolize national strength, the true leadership lies in the restraint of using nuclear weapons and the ultimate responsibility to reduce them.
 
The Promises of the US, China, and Russia Must Lead to a Resolution of the North Korean Nuclear Issue
This declaration from Shenzhen could serve as a historic starting point. At the same time, it could also remain a diplomatic rhetoric that ends without any action. The difference depends on what actions the three countries take moving forward.

South Korea also has a clear task. It must become a country that actively designs the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula and the peace order in Northeast Asia, rather than passively being incorporated into the nuclear order of great powers.

There are no winners in a nuclear war.

Therefore, there should be no bystanders in preventing nuclear war.

The promises of the US, China, and Russia must lead to a resolution of the North Korean nuclear issue. Denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula is an important test of the sincerity of that promise.

A nuclear-free Korean Peninsula. A war-free Northeast Asia. A world where humanity, culture, and nature coexist.

That is the future of peace that the declarations of the three great powers should aim for.



* This article has been translated by AI.