AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Kim Beom-soo's Acquittal Upheld in SM Acquisition Case

Kim Beom-soo, founder of Kakao and head of the Future Initiative Center, has been acquitted in both the first and appellate trials regarding allegations of colluding in price manipulation during the acquisition process of SM Entertainment. The appellate court found it difficult to confirm characteristics in Kakao's purchase orders that would indicate an intent to artificially inflate stock prices, concluding that the prosecution failed to prove that Kim and others conspired to manipulate prices.


The Seoul High Court's Criminal Division 4-1 dismissed the prosecution's appeal on November 20 in the case involving violations of the Capital Markets Act by Kim. Bae Jae-hyun, former head of Kakao's investment division, Kim Sung-soo, former head of Kakao Entertainment, and Hong Eun-taek, former CEO of Kakao, also had their first trial acquittals upheld. Ji Chang-bae, CEO of One Asia Partners, was acquitted of price manipulation charges but received a three-year prison sentence, suspended for four years, for separate embezzlement charges.


The prosecution argued that Kim and others attempted to keep SM Entertainment's stock price above the tender offer price of 120,000 won (KRW) to thwart HYBE's tender offer during the acquisition competition in February 2023. They claimed that between February 16-17 and 27, they conspired with One Asia Partners to purchase approximately 110 billion won (KRW) worth of shares, manipulating prices through high buy and sell orders.


The appellate court focused on how the actual orders were executed. It noted that market purchases could influence prices, and judging legality based solely on that influence would broaden the scope of punishment excessively. After reviewing trading records, the court determined that there was insufficient evidence to show that the transactions were aimed at artificially raising or controlling prices. The court concluded that the evidence presented by the prosecution did not sufficiently establish the intent to manipulate prices or any conspiracy among the defendants.


The first trial in October of last year also found it difficult to conclude that there were manipulative orders based on the timing and patterns of the purchase orders. The court deemed the testimony of Lee Jun-ho, former head of investment strategy at Kakao Entertainment, which the prosecution presented as supporting evidence of Kim's involvement, to be unreliable. In September, during the appellate trial's closing arguments, the prosecution sought a 15-year prison sentence and a fine of 500 million won (KRW) for Kim, along with a request for the recovery of approximately 127.2 billion won (KRW).


Immediately after the ruling, Kim issued a statement saying, "Today's verdict is a significant turning point in resolving the uncertainties that have surrounded Kakao for the past three years." He added that in the era of artificial intelligence (AI), Kakao must open new paths for growth, stating, "It is time for structural and bold changes for a resurgence."





* This article has been translated by AI.