AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Takaichi's First Visit to China Highlights Defense Policy and Party Congress Variables


Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi concluded her first visit to China since taking office, stating, "Japan's position on Taiwan is as per the 1972 Japan-China Joint Communiqué." However, she did not address China's demand to retract her parliamentary response regarding Taiwan in case of a contingency, and a formal meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping did not take place. The resumption of dialogue between the two countries is expected to be influenced by Japan's defense policy revision at the end of the year and China's Communist Party Congress next year.

Takaichi made these remarks during a press conference in Shenzhen, China, following the conclusion of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit on November 19. She emphasized that there is "no change in the status of the four political documents" that define Japan-China relations, including the 1972 Joint Communiqué. She added, "China is an important neighboring country," and stressed the importance of dialogue and communication due to existing issues and challenges.

In the 1972 Joint Communiqué that announced the normalization of diplomatic relations between China and Japan, China stated that Taiwan is an inseparable part of its territory, and Japan expressed that it "fully understands and respects" this position. China has demanded that Takaichi retract or amend her parliamentary response suggesting the possibility of collective self-defense in the event of a Taiwan contingency to normalize Japan-China relations. According to the Asahi Shimbun, China has also requested reaffirmation of the positions outlined in the four political documents, including the Joint Communiqué. While Takaichi reaffirmed the status of the basic documents, she left the contentious response unchanged.

During the two days of the APEC summit, the two leaders had three brief encounters. Most were ceremonial occasions where President Xi, as the host, welcomed leaders from various countries. Takaichi seized the short opportunity to express gratitude for the invitation and congratulations on hosting. On November 19, they briefly held hands and exchanged words for about 10 seconds, but Xi only nodded in response. Despite the favorable conditions for the host country, no formal meeting was held, and the annual Japan-China summit that has been held since 2022 during APEC has been interrupted. The gap in summits has now exceeded one year since October of last year.

In negotiations for a formal meeting, reaffirming the four political documents, including the Joint Communiqué, was mentioned as a compromise, but the two governments could not find common ground, according to the Nihon Keizai Shimbun (Nikkei). Takaichi also did not take the initiative to facilitate a meeting. Her statement that there is no change in the status of the basic documents came just before her return home after the APEC schedule had concluded. There was an early sentiment within the Japanese government that a meeting at this APEC would be difficult.

Japan and China Face Major Events Next Year

Japan's lack of urgency for a meeting at this APEC was also influenced by the upcoming year-end defense policy schedule. The Japanese government plans to revise three major security-related documents, including the national security strategy, and prepare a budget reflecting increased defense spending. China has criticized Japan's strengthening of its defense capabilities as "new militarism." Even if a meeting were to occur at APEC, there is a high likelihood that China would react again at the end of the year, leading to a view within the Japanese government that there is little benefit in focusing on improving relations now, according to Nikkei.

China also has little reason to rush. In the second half of next year, a leadership reshuffle is expected at the quinquennial Communist Party Congress. Analysts suggest that during this politically unstable period, China will adopt a cautious approach to its relationship with Japan, which has many contentious issues, including historical matters. There are also speculations about how long the Takaichi administration will last.

Additionally, Takaichi's term as president of the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) lasts until September next year, and if rival candidates emerge, she will have to hold a party leadership election. In 2028, elections for Taiwan's presidency in January, Japan's House of Councillors in the summer, and the U.S. presidential election in November will follow. With significant events lined up that could shake domestic politics and regional dynamics in both countries over the next two years, there are many variables in determining the timing for resuming dialogue.

However, opportunities are not entirely absent. Wang Yi, the Chinese Foreign Minister, mentioned the 55th anniversary of the normalization of diplomatic relations between China and Japan during a meeting with former Japanese Foreign Minister Takeaki Iwaya, who visited China in September. However, the anniversary in September next year coincides with the timing of the Communist Party Congress. Shin Kawashima, a professor at the University of Tokyo, told Nikkei, "If relations between China and Japan are to improve, the reference point would be by March next year, when China holds the National People's Congress."

Meanwhile, while political dialogue has stalled, economic issues continue to accumulate. China's export restrictions on rare earths show no signs of easing. As Japanese companies rely on China for rare earth procurement, prolonged or intensified regulations could burden various industries, including automotive, electronic components, and semiconductors. Facing economic slowdown, China has begun to show a more proactive attitude toward economic exchanges with Japan, which is a positive sign. However, Nikkei analyzed that without political backing, such movements are unlikely to lead to substantial improvement in relations.

With the conclusion of the APEC hosted by China, opportunities for the two leaders to meet will be limited for the time being. As export restrictions may continue without a political solution, Japan faces an increasing need to expand its procurement sources and production bases to Southeast Asia and Australia while considering the impact on its business with China.





* This article has been translated by AI.