Cheating using artificial intelligence (AI) is shaking the trust in exams. Cases have been detected in college entrance exams, national qualification tests, middle and high school internal assessments, and university classrooms. Ensuring fairness in corporate hiring evaluations has also become a pressing issue. As AI becomes more commonplace, the methods of cheating may diversify. Strengthening supervision and enhancing detection technology are necessary. However, merely tightening surveillance in exam rooms will not resolve the issue. We must ask ourselves what we are trying to verify through exams and what opportunities we intend to provide to individuals.
Exams are a mechanism of fairness that our society has built over time. Standardized questions and grading criteria reduce the potential for subjective judgment by evaluators. In fields where specialized knowledge is directly linked to life, safety, and rights, rigorous knowledge verification is even more critical. However, just because scores are objective does not mean they can fully assess a person's capabilities and qualities. While we can verify how much someone knows, it is difficult to determine how that knowledge will be applied based solely on scores. AI has made it challenging to judge abilities based on answers alone. The quality of the answers or the excellence of the results does not necessarily indicate the author's understanding and reasoning skills. Using AI to present one's abilities is undoubtedly a form of cheating. Ultimately, it is a matter of honesty and responsibility. We must question whether the process was as legitimate as the outcome.
For a long time, our society has regarded grades and academic credentials as indicators of outstanding talent. However, high intellectual ability does not guarantee correct judgment. There have been numerous instances where individuals, despite being well-versed in laws and regulations, have violated principles, and those with expertise have ignored the safety and rights of others. Events that have eroded social trust are deeply intertwined with a lack of ethical awareness and responsibility rather than ignorance. Acquiring skills and using those skills correctly are two different matters. It is time to reflect this difference in our selection criteria.
Quantifying character as a separate score is not the solution. A brief interview may not prove a person's character. If evaluators' preferences or biases come into play, even the fairness that score-based exams have maintained could be undermined. We need to consider how to assess judgment in situations where interests conflict, as well as the consideration for others and the responsibilities that come with choices, while maintaining the function of verifying knowledge and expertise. Evaluators must also exhibit humility and ethical responsibility, but a fair system that does not rely on individual goodwill must come first.
Evaluation systems are not merely scales measuring already acquired abilities. They also serve as standards showing what abilities society values and what attitudes it rewards. In a society where scores dictate success, both schools and students are likely to cling to scores. Conversely, if we respect honest judgment and responsibility toward the community alongside intellectual achievement, the direction of learning could change. Changing evaluation criteria is about deciding what kind of individuals we want to cultivate, who we want to provide opportunities to, and whom we want to entrust with authority.
The spread of AI cheating also presents an opportunity to reconsider the premises of knowledge-based evaluation. The humanities have long contemplated human dignity, respect for others, and communal responsibility, which are now values that cannot be ignored in education and selection processes. A society that misuses knowledge may be more dangerous than one that lacks knowledge. In an era where AI generates answers, exams must not only assess the ability to obtain those answers but also inquire about the individuals who will use them.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.