The real estate market is difficult to read, and homeownership is challenging.
The excess profit recovery system has been in place for 20 years. Experiences with exemptions and delayed assessments have been limited. According to government statistics, about 1.7 billion won (KRW) has been collected nationwide as of the end of last year. However, the anticipated amount recently notified for a single complex in the Eunma Apartment in Gangnam, Seoul, exceeds 2 trillion won (KRW). While this amount may change by the time of completion, it is essential to assess whether residents are prepared to handle such large sums.
Residents urgently need to know how much they must prepare and by when. The government must answer where the collected funds will be spent and what changes will be made. While residents prepare to pay, the government must also be ready to utilize those funds. If the excess profit recovery system is to be revised, this is where it should begin.
Five years after moving in, now facing a hefty burden.
The Banpo Hyundai complex was completed five years ago. This month, the association received a preliminary notification of a burden fee close to 18 billion won (KRW). This amount is not yet finalized.
The recent controversy over the statute of limitations for assessments ultimately revolved around when the burden fees can be imposed. Residents want to know when their obligations will be finalized. While confirming the last day for assessments, residents had to wait to determine how much money they should prepare. If the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport revises the system, it should start by reducing this waiting time.
The basis for pricing is the completion date. Even if the assessment is delayed, it does not reflect the increase in housing prices after completion. The remaining issue for residents is uncertainty. They must move in without knowing the final burden fee and plan for loans or retirement funds. The calculations that the government has not completed are holding back residents' lives.
Local governments responsible for assessments should review costs and deductions during construction and, as completion approaches, work with the association to resolve remaining issues. The preliminary assessment amount should be communicated based on the completion date price and actual costs, followed by a legal review for finalization. Current laws generally require assessments to be made within five months after completion, with exceptions for reductions and reviews. There is room to expedite administrative preparations while ensuring residents have time to raise objections.
If assessments are delayed, the administrative agency should inform residents of the reasons for the delay, remaining procedures, and expected finalization timelines. It is time to change the system where residents must inquire at the district office to know when to prepare their funds.
Let's calculate the shared costs and excess profit recovery together.
The funds collected through the excess profit recovery system are not legally classified as taxes. The reconstruction burden fee falls under the 'monetary payment obligations other than taxes' as defined by the Basic Act on Burden Fee Management. It is money recovered from the excess profits, which are the increases in housing prices before and after reconstruction, minus normal increases and development costs. This differs from the basis and calculation methods for member contributions to cover construction costs or public contributions due to eased floor area ratios.
For residents, all of this money comes from their own pockets. Even if they agree with the intent to share development profits, the immediate cash flow issues for actual residents remain. Each time they receive a contribution notice, they should know how much more they need to prepare for the excess profit recovery.
Residents' calculations begin when they agree to establish the association. It should be indicated whether the estimated contribution notice includes the excess profit recovery. Initially, it may be sufficient to show the range of expected burdens based on different assumptions regarding housing prices, construction costs, and completion dates. As the project progresses, the expected amounts should be adjusted to reflect actual prices and costs, with explanations for any changes. Residents need to understand under what conditions their burdens may increase or decrease to decide whether to agree to the establishment of the association.
After the project approval, the local government responsible for assessments must notify the association of the anticipated amount and update it annually. This obligation already exists. Eunma has also gone through this process. However, the notified amount is based on the assumption of completion in 2035 and does not reflect individual long-term holding reductions. It is easy to misunderstand the average amount as the amount each household will pay. The association should communicate the expected burdens and calculation basis to each member.
The payment plan received by members should include both the contribution and the expected amount for the excess profit recovery. This allows residents to see at a glance the amounts they have already paid and will pay, along with their respective payment timelines. If the contribution includes the excess profit recovery, it should be distinguished to prevent double counting, and if separate, the total expected burden should be presented. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport should prepare a standard format for integrated guidance, and local governments should verify the calculation basis provided by the association. This will reduce the effort residents need to find and add up amounts scattered across various documents.
There are also mechanisms to prepare funds separately. The primary payer for the excess profit recovery is already the association. Current laws allow for the advance collection of all or part of the anticipated amount according to the management plan and deposit it in a designated account. The principal and interest calculated according to legal formulas can be deducted from the final burden fee. Associations wishing to use this can connect the payment schedule with partial deposits through legal procedures.
Advance deposits are a supplementary measure that associations can choose based on members' financial situations. For residents who borrow to pay in advance, interest may increase. It may be worth considering methods to prepare some funds as completion approaches. Even if they have paid in advance, the benefits of reductions and payment deferrals must be protected. It is necessary to determine when to refund any excess payments and how to settle if a member changes. The government should not resolve its delayed calculations through residents' prepayments.
Knowing whose house my money helped build.
Half of the reconstruction burden fee goes to the national government, while the rest is allocated to metropolitan and local governments. The national share goes into the Housing and Urban Fund and undergoes a redistribution process by local governments, while the portion directly allocated to local governments goes into legally designated funds and special accounts. The funds divided among various agencies make it difficult for residents to trace the final usage. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport needs to collect data based on common standards to show how much was contributed to which projects.
It should be clear how much will be contributed to the construction of public rental apartments through the excess profit recovery and what inconveniences will be addressed in older rental housing. This could also support long-awaited projects for vulnerable housing groups who have been waiting for budgets for a long time. Residents need explanations about where the money will be spent rather than just the names of the accounts.
The usage plan should be announced before the funds come in. Current enforcement regulations stipulate that local governments must notify the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport of the accounts and operational plans by the completion approval date. This plan should include the projects, beneficiaries, and timelines, and it should be made public to residents. Expanding advance collections should also expedite the announcement of plans, and if less is collected than expected or if funds arrive late, explanations should be provided on what will be adjusted first.
There is also a reason to consider dedicated special accounts or funds. It should be possible to verify how much has come in through the excess profit recovery, how much has been spent on which projects, and how much remains. Even if existing accounts are used, the flow of this money should be recorded separately. Funds transferred to or deposited with other agencies should be distinguished from the money actually spent on housing improvements, and performance should be assessed based on the amounts invested in final projects and their outcomes.
There are points worth noting from the lottery fund. Money generated from lottery sales is also used to support low-income rental housing. The performance of projects funded by money sent to other funds should be evaluated, and the operational status, including income and expenditures, should be disclosed every six months. In fact, the housing and urban fund-supported lease and purchase rental projects have also been evaluated by the lottery fund. Although the methods of collecting money differ, the procedures for tracking what was done with that money after passing through various agencies are also necessary for the excess profit recovery.
Just as payment notices are sent, the results of usage can also be communicated. It should be shown how much was contributed to which projects and how many households' living conditions improved, comparing the initial plans with actual results. If multiple resources were contributed, the amount covered by the excess profit recovery should also be disclosed. Explanations should be provided for any remaining funds and why they could not be used, and larger or long-term projects should undergo external verification.
If existing housing welfare budgets were replaced with the excess profit recovery, that fact should also be disclosed. To assess the effectiveness of the system, it is essential to know how much new support has increased. It is the government's responsibility to find more urgent housing needs outside the burdened complexes and explain that the funds were used where they were needed.
What if I knew that the money I paid contributed to someone else's home? If long-delayed improvements to living conditions became possible with that money, it could bring a sense of fulfillment alongside the burden. Knowing where the money went and whose lives it changed makes a difference. The government should provide more than just a payment notice; it should offer a promise of what will be done with that money and the actual results of what has changed.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.