The combination of generative artificial intelligence (AI) and ultra-small wearable devices has brought the integrity of national exams and college admissions to the forefront of legislative concerns. Following the discovery of a test-taker using AI smart glasses to evade supervision during the Law School Admission Test (LEET) in July, a shocking case emerged this year where the top scorer in the tax accountant exam achieved a perfect score using a tiny camera and AI.
Colleges and secondary schools are not exempt from this issue. A nationwide survey conducted by the Ministry of Education across more than 180 general universities revealed that from January 2020 to August this year, there were 19 recorded incidents of AI-related cheating in regular university exams. Cheating incidents using smart glasses were also reported in essay tests at Yonsei University and the University of Seoul, as well as in secondary school assessments.
According to a comprehensive report by Aju Economy on November 20, lawmakers from both ruling and opposition parties introduced a total of eight legislative proposals, including seven amendments to the Higher Education Act and one amendment to the Qualification Basic Act, between November 16 and 18, in response to the upcoming 2027 College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT).
Bipartisan Support for Increasing Exam Bans from 3 to 10 Years
Both ruling and opposition lawmakers have expressed a common concern that the current law, which stipulates 'test invalidation and a one-year suspension of eligibility,' is insufficient to prevent and penalize cheating using advanced devices. However, there are differences in the specifics of the proposed penalties and their application among the lawmakers.Regarding the suspension of eligibility, the proposed amendments set varying suspension periods of '3 years, 5 years, and 10 years.'
The proposal by Democratic Party lawmaker Park Sun-won, introduced on November 17, stipulates a 3-year suspension of eligibility only for serious cheating involving the exchange of answers with external parties using AI or information and communication devices.
In contrast, the proposals by Democratic Party lawmaker Ko Min-jeong, introduced on November 16, and People Power Party lawmaker Kim Hee-jung, introduced on November 17, suggest raising the suspension period for CSAT cheaters from the current one year to five years, considering fairness with civil service and national qualification exams.
The proposal by Democratic Party lawmaker Kim Moon-soo, introduced on November 16, is designed to suspend eligibility for up to five years based on the circumstances of the cheating.
The proposals that set the suspension period at 10 years were introduced by Democratic Party lawmakers Jeong Cheong-rae and Han Jeong-ae on November 18. Jeong's proposal stipulates a 10-year ban on CSAT eligibility for those who bring in smart glasses or use AI technology, as well as for those who refuse to comply with exam supervisors' requests for searches to confirm cheating.
Han Jeong-ae's proposal also extends the suspension period to a maximum of 10 years and specifies that the strengthened regulations will apply retroactively to those caught cheating in the CSAT conducted on November 19.
In addition to eligibility restrictions, proposals have been introduced that include criminal penalties and sanctions for managing academic records and histories. Park Sun-won has proposed new penalties for real-time answer provision and for organizing or facilitating cheating for profit. Jeong Cheong-rae's proposal includes grounds for canceling university admission in cases of detected cheating and criminal penalty provisions. Kim Hee-jung's proposal mandates that the head of the school discipline students who engage in cheating, while Kim Moon-soo's proposal establishes provisions for the Ministry of Education to manage records of cheating and share them with all higher education institutions.
New Legislative Proposals for Technology and System Defenses Against AI Cheating
Unlike the proposals that strengthen post-cheating penalties, some legislative proposals focus on explicitly defining technical and physical barriers and enforcement powers within exam venues.The proposal by People Power Party lawmaker Park Jeong-hoon, introduced on November 18, includes measures to restrict AI services from generating answers during exam periods instead of extending the eligibility suspension period. It imposes an obligation on the Minister of Education to establish and implement measures to prevent the misuse of AI for cheating and provides a legal basis for exam management organizations to collaborate with domestic and international AI companies and information service providers (Article 34, Paragraphs 14 and 15).
Specifically, it allows exam administrators to request technical measures from AI companies to limit image recognition, analysis, and answer generation for exam questions, while specifying the types of exams, target questions, and applicable times to minimize the impact on general users' service usage.
A proposal by People Power Party lawmaker Kim Wi-sang, which addresses national qualification exams, explicitly states the powers of enforcement and investigation in exam venues. This proposal, introduced on November 17, grants exam managers or the relevant minister the authority to conduct signal detection and search candidates' belongings during exams, as well as the authority to request the submission of communication data and other materials from relevant agencies for post-verification, along with new penalty provisions for those engaging in cheating with advanced devices.
All Eight Proposals Currently in the National Assembly's 'Receipt' Stage
As of November 20, a review of the National Assembly's legislative information system and the status of the Education Committee shows that all eight proposals introduced by both ruling and opposition parties between November 16 and 18 are currently in the 'receipt' stage (awaiting referral to the relevant committee). The proposals by lawmakers Ko Min-jeong, Kim Moon-soo, Park Sun-won, Kim Hee-jung, and Kim Wi-sang, introduced on November 16 and 17, have been referred to the Education Committee or are in the referral process, while the proposals by Park Jeong-hoon, Jeong Cheong-rae, and Han Jeong-ae, received on November 18, are also awaiting referral to the relevant committee, meaning that formal combined reviews have not yet begun.During the upcoming review process by the National Assembly's Education Committee, there are calls for careful refinements to ensure legal consistency and practical enforceability, alongside the strengthening of post-cheating penalties.
A National Assembly official stated, "The proposal to retroactively apply the strengthened regulations to those caught cheating in the CSAT conducted on November 19 may violate the constitutional principle against retroactive legislation and the principle of excessive punishment, warranting careful examination." The official added, "The varying suspension periods of three, five, and ten years for CSAT eligibility in the proposed laws should also be derived through social consensus to determine an appropriate standard."
Furthermore, regarding measures to prevent cheating, it is essential to comprehensively consider whether schools can secure personnel and budgets to implement these measures, whether preventive facilities can be installed, and whether operations can be conducted on the day of the CSAT without disrupting candidates' exam participation.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.