AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Divergent Views on Introducing Insurance Sales Specialist Companies

The introduction of 'insurance sales specialist companies' has sparked sharp divisions between the corporate insurance agency (GA) sector and the insurance industry. The GA sector argues that since they already perform some functions of insurance companies, they should be granted corresponding legal status and responsibilities. In contrast, the life and non-life insurance sectors contend that the necessity of creating a separate industry and the benefits to consumers have not been sufficiently proven.

During a discussion on the introduction of insurance sales specialist companies, co-hosted by Democratic Party lawmaker Min Byung-deok and People Power Party lawmaker Joo Ho-young on November 20 at the National Assembly, there was agreement on the need to strengthen the legal responsibilities of GAs, but differences emerged regarding the establishment of a separate industry and the expansion of their scope of work.

Insurance sales specialist companies would grant GAs a separate legal status, expanding their scope of work and authority. Currently, GAs operate based on sales commissions and incentive payment criteria set by insurance companies. If the system is implemented, GAs would have legally guaranteed authority to negotiate recruitment commissions and some business expenses, potentially enhancing their bargaining power. Their scope of work would also expand to include contract maintenance and management, as well as acting on behalf of small insurance payouts.

Currently, there are proposed amendments to the Insurance Business Act pending in the National Assembly, introduced by lawmakers Min and Joo. Both bills would allow corporations meeting certain criteria to register as insurance sales specialist companies. However, Min's proposal adds support and representation for insurance claims by GAs and specifies the direct liability of sales specialist companies, while Joo's proposal focuses on mandating minimum capital maintenance and liability insurance.

The GA sector emphasizes the need to assign responsibilities commensurate with the actual work performed. Jang Nam-hoon, executive director of the Insurance GA Association, stated, "Improving the current sales structure, where the subject of responsibility is unclear, and providing clear legal responsibilities and compensation capabilities for sales organizations is the starting point for consumer protection."

Regarding the negotiation rights for business expenses, they countered that limiting the scope to contract maintenance costs would not lead to premium increases. They explained that since the method involves distributing some of the maintenance costs previously used by insurance companies to GAs performing post-management tasks, it would not affect the total business expenses or premiums.

However, the existing insurance industry expressed concerns about potential side effects from the expansion of authority. Choi Jong-soo, executive director of the General Insurance Association, pointed out that the results of business expense negotiations could lead to varying premiums across sales channels, and the responsibility could become unclear during the process of acting on small insurance payouts. Park Soon-keun, executive director of the Life Insurance Association, also argued that strengthening internal controls and sales responsibilities within the current system should be prioritized.

The Financial Services Commission also took a cautious stance. Lim Hyung-jun, head of the insurance division at the commission, expressed concerns that granting GAs negotiation rights for recruitment commissions and some business expenses could lead to increased consumer burdens. He introduced a simulation showing that a 500 basis point increase in commission rates could raise monthly premiums by approximately 4.8%, stating, "Since we have been pursuing improvements to the recruitment commission system, we should confirm the stabilization of the system before reviewing it in the medium to long term."




* This article has been translated by AI.