AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin Smile in Shenzhen as Focus Shifts to Trump's Miami G20

 

The trilateral summit between the United States, China, and Russia, which drew global attention, has concluded. The historical significance of the meeting, where the leaders of these three major powers gathered for the first time, cannot be understated. A joint statement was issued addressing issues such as UN reform, nuclear war prevention, and expanding oil supplies. However, no substantial breakthroughs were achieved on critical issues that are shaking the world, including the Iran-Ukraine war, US-China trade tensions, and semiconductor export controls. This has led to evaluations that, despite the grand diplomatic display, the practical outcomes were limited.


Nevertheless, when weighing the diplomatic gains, analyses suggest that Xi Jinping, the Chinese president, and Vladimir Putin, the Russian president, reaped the most benefits. President Xi showcased his influence by leveraging the advantage of hosting the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit to bring the three major powers together. The image of the three leaders seated together, particularly centered around Xi, effectively highlighted China's role as a mediator coordinating major issues at the center of the international order.


For President Putin, the summit was also a valuable opportunity. Facing Western sanctions and diplomatic isolation since the invasion of Ukraine, he conveyed the message that Russia remains a major power influencing the global order by standing shoulder to shoulder with the leaders of the US and China. Notably, while the joint statement included warnings against the abuse of the International Criminal Court's (ICC) jurisdiction, the Ukraine war was not mentioned, marking a significant achievement for him.


In contrast, President Donald Trump's report card appears relatively weak. Following the Republican Party's defeat in the midterm elections, Trump needed a chance to regain control of domestic affairs, and he partially showcased his presence by facilitating this historic trilateral meeting. However, he did not achieve clear results in finding an exit strategy for the Ukraine and Iran wars or in addressing trade issues with China.


In fact, considering that China and Russia are weighing their strategic interests amid the prolonged nature of both wars, there is little incentive for them to readily respond to US demands. Unlike the 1945 Yalta Conference, which discussed post-war order against a 'common enemy' in Nazi Germany, this summit lacked clear shared strategic goals among the three nations. Most importantly, while the US emerged as a superpower leading the international order after World War II, this summit highlighted the reality that the US president must now negotiate interests on an equal footing with the leaders of China and Russia. This symbolizes the relative shift in US influence.


As if to reflect this reality, tensions between the US and China resumed immediately after the summit. Following the implementation of new US semiconductor export controls, investigations related to Nvidia have begun. Although China extended its suspension of additional tariffs on the US for two months this month, the potential for renewed tariff conflicts remains. Particularly, if China responds to the US's strengthened semiconductor controls with restrictions on rare earth exports, the fragile trade truce between the two countries could be shaken again.


Other international issues also show little sign of resolution. Russia continues its military offensive against Ukraine, and tensions surrounding Iran in the Middle East remain high. Amid a series of attacks on oil tankers in the Strait of Hormuz, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has reportedly urged President Trump for additional airstrikes against Iran.


Ultimately, despite the historic trilateral summit, major conflicts shaking the international community remain unresolved.


In this context, attention now turns to the G20 summit scheduled for December 14-15 in Miami, USA. Xi's attendance is highly anticipated, while Putin's participation remains uncertain. It is unclear whether the three leaders will meet again, but it is evident that this meeting will serve as a stage to gauge the direction of great power diplomacy following the Shenzhen summit.


The key question is whether the discussions in Shenzhen can lead to practical agreements and resolutions on international issues. While the Shenzhen summit demonstrated that great powers can engage in dialogue, the dialogue itself does not guarantee peace and stability. There are concerns that, during the process of the three major powers coordinating their interests, the voices of Ukraine and Europe, as well as those of US allies like South Korea and Japan, may be sidelined.


Now, less than a month after the Shenzhen summit, President Trump will welcome major world leaders, including Xi Jinping, to his home turf in Miami. If Xi and Putin secured gains in Shenzhen, the focus will be on how much influence Trump can exert in Miami. As the new year approaches with a Democratic-led Congress set to take office, it remains to be seen whether he can lay the groundwork for a counteroffensive to regain control of domestic affairs through diplomatic achievements.





* This article has been translated by AI.