The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy's official development assistance (ODA) project has had its evaluation changed from a reduction to an improvement during the performance evaluation process, but the reasons for this change were not included in the final opinion report. Following the easing of the judgment, next year's budget has actually increased by 13.7%.
According to a report titled 'Evaluation of Official Development Assistance (ODA) Projects' published by the National Assembly Budget Policy Office, among the 25 evaluation units where written evaluations and final judgments were confirmed, 18 had their final judgments eased compared to the written evaluations. Of these, 14 did not have the reasons for the change noted in the final opinion report, and there were no cases where the final judgment was strengthened compared to the written evaluation.
The support for industrial cooperation and development is also one of the projects where the reasons for the change were not noted. This project received a 'reduction' judgment in the written evaluation and was classified as 'undetermined' in the face-to-face evaluation.
The Ministry of Trade requested the deletion of the reduction opinion during the evaluation process. They cited the content presented in the presidential work report that 'ODA will be used as leverage to expand support for our country's companies' overseas expansion.'
As a result, the final opinion report included a recommendation to change the judgment to 'project improvement' and to redesign performance indicators to be results-oriented. However, the specific reasons for the change from reduction to project improvement were not noted.
Additionally, the budget has increased. The budget for industrial cooperation and development support for 2026 was 31.21 billion won (KRW), but the government proposal for 2027 has been set at 35.47 billion won (KRW), an increase of 4.26 billion won (KRW) or 13.7% over the year.
The Budget Policy Office pointed out that for projects where the judgment has been eased, it is necessary to consider measures to have the evaluation team note the reasons for the judgment change in the final opinion report. They also suggested that if the relevant ministry has prepared the budget in a direction contrary to the evaluation recommendations, they should disclose the reasons in the budget proposal explanatory materials.
The performance evaluation of ODA projects is directly linked to the use of the budget. In the integrated financial project performance evaluation, projects that received a reduction judgment are required to request a budget that is more than 15% lower than the previous year's budget for the next year. If the evaluation results have changed, it is necessary to confirm the process and reasons so that the linkage between evaluation and budget preparation can function properly.
A Budget Policy Office official stated, 'In particular, since the support for industrial cooperation and development has seen an easing of evaluation results followed by an increase in budget, it is necessary to examine the basis for the judgment change and the increase together. There should be an explanation of how the need to continue the project and the need for improvement in performance indicators have been reflected.'
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.