Diplomacy speaks two languages: one is words, and the other is actions. If the joint declaration of a summit is verbal diplomacy, then the reception at the airport, the order of meetings, seating arrangements at banquets, and the layout of photos in newspapers represent action diplomacy. Sometimes, actions explain more than words.
The Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit held in Shenzhen, China, in November 2026 vividly illustrated this aspect of diplomacy.
Chinese President Xi Jinping hosted a historic trilateral summit with U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. He also held a summit with South Korean President Lee Jae-myung. However, no separate bilateral meeting took place with Japan's Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi.
Although they attended the same international conference, the diplomatic treatment and outcomes for the leaders varied.
This should not be interpreted simply as China liking Korea and disliking Japan. In international politics, national sentiments always move in tandem with calculations of national interests. The hospitality shown by China to Korea must also be understood within the context of strategic considerations regarding Northeast Asia and the global order.
In diplomacy, bouquets are beautiful. However, what lies behind them—the national interests—are far more important.
What Korea must recognize through this APEC summit is not China's goodwill but rather China's needs.
China is currently engaged in fierce strategic competition with the United States. The scope of this competition is broadening, encompassing semiconductors, artificial intelligence, advanced manufacturing, supply chains, finance, and trade order. China maintains a strategic cooperative relationship with Russia, while tensions with Japan persist over issues related to Taiwan and historical conflicts.
Substantial resolution of Korea-China FTA service and investment follow-up negotiations... Breaking the deadlock on the Korean ban
In this environment, Korea is an important country for China.Korea is an ally of the United States and a major economic partner of China. It possesses globally competitive industries in semiconductors, batteries, automobiles, shipbuilding, and electronics. It also has significant international competitiveness in culture and content industries. For China, there are ample economic and diplomatic reasons to manage its relationship with Korea stably.
Korea cannot afford to ignore China either. China is a massive consumer market and a manufacturing hub, holding a crucial position in the supply chains of key minerals and intermediate goods. Moreover, China's role in the peace of the Korean Peninsula and the North Korean nuclear issue cannot be overlooked.
Thus, the improvement of Korea-China relations is not a one-sided gift from either side; it is a diplomatic choice made possible by mutual necessity.
The most concrete economic outcome of this summit is the declaration of substantial resolution in the follow-up negotiations for the Korea-China Free Trade Agreement (FTA) in the service and investment sectors.
The Korea-China FTA came into effect in December 2015. Follow-up negotiations for additional openings in the service and investment sectors began in March 2018. However, due to differences in positions between the two countries, progress was stalled for a long time, with periods exceeding four years without official negotiations.
The situation changed in 2026. Following a Korea-China summit in January, negotiations gained momentum, and after five rounds of official talks and several high-level consultations, a substantial resolution was declared on November 18, marking 8 years and 8 months since negotiations began.
Of course, a substantial resolution does not mean immediate final implementation. Some technical document negotiations and formal signing processes remain. The important fact is that both countries have resolved a long-standing deadlock through political decisions and practical negotiations.
This negotiation signifies an expansion of trade relations from a goods-centered approach to services and investments.
Notably, China's commitment to provide Korea with most-favored-nation treatment in the content sector, including films and games, is significant. Improvements in market access are also expected in various service sectors, including tourism, law, and finance.
Expand economic cooperation while guarding against economic dependency
However, it is essential to distinguish between the text of the agreement and market realities.Most-favored-nation treatment guarantees that no less favorable treatment will be given than that provided to other countries. However, this does not automatically ensure the screening of Korean films in China or the issuance of game licenses. Domestic regulations and review systems in China, as well as the transparency of actual market access, remain crucial.
Ultimately, the outcome of this FTA negotiation will be determined not by the announcement at the summit but by how fairly and freely Korean companies can operate in the Chinese market.
The Korean government must manage this situation with a cool head.
In the cultural content market, efforts should be made to expand the actual entry of films, games, broadcasting, and performances. Opportunities to enhance the competitiveness of Korean companies in tourism, healthcare, distribution, and finance should also be sought. At the same time, follow-up procedures must be thoroughly managed to ensure the protection of intellectual property rights, transparency in administrative processes, and the safeguarding of investors' rights.
While expanding economic cooperation, it is essential to guard against economic dependency.
The experience of the rapid deterioration of Korea-China relations following Korea's decision to deploy THAAD in 2016 serves as an important lesson. Excessive economic dependence on a specific country can lead to diplomatic conflicts spilling over into the daily lives of businesses and citizens.
Improving Korea-China relations is a different issue from increasing dependency on China again.
This is especially true in the semiconductor industry.
Korea's semiconductor industry possesses global competitiveness. Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix play significant roles in memory semiconductors and high-bandwidth memory (HBM). China is both a massive semiconductor consumer market and a competitor actively fostering its domestic semiconductor industry.
The United States is restricting the transfer of advanced semiconductors, manufacturing equipment, and artificial intelligence-related technologies to China. Meanwhile, China is pursuing technological self-reliance and supply chain stabilization. Korean companies are being asked to make complex choices in this context.
However, this issue should not be simplified to a choice between the U.S. and China.
The criteria for South Korea's choices must be clear: to protect the legitimate economic activities and technological competitiveness of our companies while upholding national security and international commitments.
The outflow of advanced technology must be prevented. Compliance with U.S. export controls and related regulations is also necessary. At the same time, economic cooperation with the Chinese market should be maintained reasonably within permissible limits.
Semiconductors are not merely export products; they are strategic assets that determine Korea's industrial sovereignty and future growth potential.
Unbridgeable differences between China and Japan over Taiwan
It is impossible to discuss Korea-China relations without mentioning Japan.
While a Korea-China summit was held at this APEC, a Japan-China summit did not take place. The conflict between China and Japan is significantly influenced by differing security perceptions regarding Taiwan. Takaichi's mention of Japan's security and collective self-defense issues in the event of a Taiwan contingency has heightened tensions between the two countries.
China regards the Taiwan issue as a core interest. Japan believes that the stability of the Taiwan Strait is closely linked to its own security.
The positions of the two countries are unlikely to be easily reconciled.
However, Korea should not seek temporary diplomatic satisfaction by exploiting the conflict between China and Japan. Korea's diplomatic victory is not defined by China's cold shoulder toward Japan.
Korea and Japan have many areas for cooperation in economics, security, technology, and culture. Despite historical conflicts surrounding historical issues, there is a need for cooperation for future industries, supply chain stability, and peace in Northeast Asia.
Korea should not sacrifice its relationship with Japan to improve relations with China, nor should it unnecessarily worsen its relationship with China to strengthen ties with Japan.
The level of diplomacy is not determined by who is friendly with whom but by how principled and productive relationships are maintained with different countries.
The same applies to the Taiwan issue.
South Korea must uphold the principle that peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait are important. While opposing unilateral changes to the status quo through force, it must also guard against actions that unnecessarily escalate military tensions. Above all, it should pursue cautious and consistent diplomacy that does not undermine the Korea-U.S. alliance and South Korea's security.
Another outcome Korea should seek from this APEC is China's cooperation for peace on the Korean Peninsula.
President Lee Jae-myung requested President Xi Jinping to play a constructive role in easing tensions and promoting peaceful coexistence between the North and South. The Chinese side also expressed its intention to play a constructive role regarding the Korean Peninsula issue.
However, diplomatic support and practical actions are different.
North Korea has legalized its nuclear weapons policy and continues its nuclear development. The International Atomic Energy Agency recently reported movements to expand uranium enrichment facilities in Yongbyon. The denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula remains an unresolved challenge.
Korea, China, and Japan are inseparable neighbors... Diplomacy that cooperates confidently
If China genuinely desires peace on the Korean Peninsula, it must make substantial contributions to reducing North Korea's nuclear threats and creating conditions for dialogue. Korea must connect the improvement of its relations with China to these outcomes.
In this context, South Korean diplomacy is called to a higher philosophy.
We have long been accustomed to the perception of being caught between great powers. Geographically, this is not incorrect. The Korean Peninsula is where the continent meets the ocean, surrounded by great powers such as the United States, China, Japan, and Russia.
However, geographical location does not determine a nation's destiny.
South Korea has grown into a nation with global industries, technologies, democratic institutions, and cultural influence. It must now become a country that can choose for itself and propose directions for cooperation, rather than waiting for the choices of great powers.
The year 2027, marking the 35th anniversary of Korea-China diplomatic relations, is significant in this regard.
Since the establishment of diplomatic ties in 1992, Korea-China relations have rapidly developed based on economic cooperation. However, political distrust and security conflicts have accumulated, leading to several difficulties. The next 35 years should be a time not just to increase trade volume but to create an order of mutual respect, trust, fair competition, and cooperation.
The future of Korea-Japan relations is also intertwined with this.
Korea, China, and Japan have historically oscillated between conflict and exchange. However, the three countries are geographically inseparable neighbors. They are also closely connected economically. They share common challenges such as global technological innovation, aging populations, climate crises, and energy transitions.
For Northeast Asia to become a center of cooperation rather than conflict, all three countries must transcend past confrontations and design the future.
Of course, cooperation does not mean abandoning national principles. Historical truths, national sovereignty, and the safety of citizens must be respected. On that foundation, economic, cultural, scientific, technological, and human exchanges should be expanded.
The dignity of a nation lies not in how much it pressures the other country but in how it maintains principles and opens paths for cooperation even amid conflicts.
Confucius said in the Analects, 'The gentleman seeks harmony but not uniformity.' This wisdom is also necessary in today's international diplomacy.
Maintaining an alliance with the United States does not mean being hostile to China. Expanding economic cooperation with China does not mean distancing from Japan. Designing a future with Japan does not mean forgetting historical truths.
We must be able to cooperate while being different. That is the diplomacy of a mature nation.
At this APEC in Shenzhen, China sent friendly signals to Korea. South Korea should positively assess this but avoid excessive expectations or fears.
Diplomatic hospitality can be an opportunity. However, it is not in itself a national interest.
National interest is proven through the results of negotiations. Only when market access for businesses is expanded, core technologies are protected, supply chains are stabilized, and military tensions on the Korean Peninsula are reduced does diplomacy yield results.
South Korea does not need to be overly elated by China's hospitality or excessively fearful of its influence. It should pursue diplomacy that firmly strengthens its alliance with the United States, cooperates practically with China, and opens the future with Japan.
This is not diplomacy that lines up between great powers but diplomacy that confidently cooperates with them.
The purpose of diplomacy is not hospitality but national interest. The ultimate goal of national interest is the lives and peace of the people.
Diplomacy that achieves harmony while being different is the path that South Korea must choose.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.