AJP Asia Intelligence Agency

Court Upholds Gift Tax Based on Nearby Apartment Sales Price

 

A court has ruled that the tax authority's decision to impose a gift tax based on the actual transaction price of a nearby apartment from about seven months ago is justified.

According to the legal community on the 22nd, the Administrative Division 6 of the Seoul Administrative Court (Judge Na Jin-yi) ruled against plaintiff A in a lawsuit filed against the head of the Gwanak Tax Office regarding the cancellation of the gift tax assessment on October 2.

A received an apartment in Gwanak-gu, Seoul, from his father in May 2022, reporting and paying a gift tax of 63.05 million won (KRW) based on the official price of 425 million won (KRW) from the previous year.

However, the tax authority confirmed that an apartment in the adjacent building of the same complex was sold for 730 million won (KRW) in October 2021 and imposed additional gift tax based on this actual transaction price after deliberation by the Seoul Regional Tax Office's Evaluation Review Committee.

In response, A argued that "the two apartments are in different buildings and floors, and there is about a seven-month difference between the sale date and the gift date," and filed a lawsuit against the tax assessment.

The court sided with the tax authority, stating that the two apartments are located in close proximity within the same complex and have the same exclusive area and apartment price (462 million won (KRW)).

The court concluded that "it is difficult to see significant differences in sunlight, view, actual transaction frequency, and price between the two apartments."

Regarding the difference in transaction timing, the court noted that "the interval between the sale date of the comparable apartment and the gift date is about six months and 20 days, which is very close in the evaluation period," and explained that "another apartment with the same building, floor, and exclusive area as the one A received was also contracted for sale at 730 million won (KRW)."

The court also rejected A's claim that there were special circumstances due to a significant drop in apartment prices from 2022 to 2023.

Additionally, based on data from the Korea Real Estate Agency and KB Real Estate, the court stated that "there was no significant fluctuation in apartment prices in Gwanak-gu between the transaction dates, and the price decline mainly occurred after the gift," asserting that "it is difficult to see special circumstances that would make the properties incomparable."





* This article has been translated by AI.