
Central Labor Relations Commission in Sejong City. 2023.10.13[Photo by Yoo Dae-gil]
A ruling has determined that Hanwha Ocean must engage in negotiations with cafeteria workers employed by its subcontractor. This decision reflects a broader recognition of the primary contractor's employer status following the implementation of the Yellow Envelope Law.
On June 15, the Central Labor Relations Commission upheld its initial ruling against Hanwha Ocean's appeal regarding the confirmation of the union representing subcontracted workers from the Metal Workers' Union in Geoje Tongyeong Goseong. However, it acknowledged Hanwha Ocean's employer status over the subcontractor, Wellive.
The commission stated, "Hanwha Ocean is in a position to substantially and concretely control and determine the working conditions. Improvements to the aging facilities and equipment in the kitchens, laundry rooms, and shuttle buses where union members work cannot be implemented solely by Wellive without the cooperation and approval of Hanwha Ocean, the owner of those facilities."
In response to the ruling, Hanwha Ocean is reportedly considering legal action. If the company contests the commission's decision, it can file an administrative lawsuit within 15 days from the date of receiving the ruling.
Concerns about the broad interpretation of employer status have emerged among businesses. The Korea Employers Federation criticized the ruling, stating, "The Central Labor Relations Commission's decision that Hanwha Ocean must negotiate with Metal Workers' Union members working for Wellive in areas such as industrial safety contradicts the Ministry of Employment and Labor's revised interpretation guidelines for labor laws."
The federation emphasized that according to the ministry's guidelines, in-house cafeterias fall under areas where general directives are recognized under subcontracting agreements, representing a typical example that does not involve structural control by the primary contractor.
On June 15, the Central Labor Relations Commission upheld its initial ruling against Hanwha Ocean's appeal regarding the confirmation of the union representing subcontracted workers from the Metal Workers' Union in Geoje Tongyeong Goseong. However, it acknowledged Hanwha Ocean's employer status over the subcontractor, Wellive.
The commission stated, "Hanwha Ocean is in a position to substantially and concretely control and determine the working conditions. Improvements to the aging facilities and equipment in the kitchens, laundry rooms, and shuttle buses where union members work cannot be implemented solely by Wellive without the cooperation and approval of Hanwha Ocean, the owner of those facilities."
In response to the ruling, Hanwha Ocean is reportedly considering legal action. If the company contests the commission's decision, it can file an administrative lawsuit within 15 days from the date of receiving the ruling.
Concerns about the broad interpretation of employer status have emerged among businesses. The Korea Employers Federation criticized the ruling, stating, "The Central Labor Relations Commission's decision that Hanwha Ocean must negotiate with Metal Workers' Union members working for Wellive in areas such as industrial safety contradicts the Ministry of Employment and Labor's revised interpretation guidelines for labor laws."
The federation emphasized that according to the ministry's guidelines, in-house cafeterias fall under areas where general directives are recognized under subcontracting agreements, representing a typical example that does not involve structural control by the primary contractor.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.